Udlændinge- og Integrationsudvalget 2023-24
UUI Alm.del
Offentligt
2805428_0001.png
Violations by Article and by State
n
io
nt
ve
on
C
ice
e
tw
th
ed
of
sh
s
le
ni
tic
pu
Ar
or
er
ed
th
ns
tri
O
tio
be
ec
to
el
e
ot
fre
tn
n
o
gh
io
tt
Ri
at
gh
uc
Ri
ed
ty
o
tt
er
gh
op
Ri
pr
n
of
io
n
at
tio
in
ec
rim
ot
sc
Pr
y
di
ed
of
m
re
on
iti
ve
ib
cti
oh
fe
Pr
ef
an
n
ry
o
tio
ar
tt
m
cia
gh
o
so
Ri
tt
as
gh
d
Ri
an
y
bl
n
m
d
se
sio
as
es
an
e
pr
of
nc
ex
m
of
cie
do
ns
m
ily
ee
co
m
Fr
do
t,
fa
ee
gh
Fr
nd
ou n a
th igio te
of rel iva
pr
m
do
or
aw
tf
ee
tl
ec life
Fr
ou
sp
re
ith
o
tw
tt
en
gh
m
t
Ri
sh
en
ni
m
pu
ce
o
or
N
s
nf
ng
-e
di
on
ee
N
oc
pr
²
of
al
th
tri
ng
ir
Le
fa
y
a
rit
o
cu
tt
se
gh
d
ur
Ri
an
bo
ty
la
er
d
ce
lib
or
o
/f
tt
ry
gh
3
ve
Ri
sla
ns
of
tio
la
on
io
n
iti
lv
tio
ib
na
ga
oh
tio
Pr
sti
di
t
ve
in
on
en
C
m
ive
at
ct
fe
tre
ef
g
in
of
ad
ck
gr
²
La
de
re
rtu
or
to
an
n
of
m
tio
on
hu
ga
iti
In
sti
ib
ve
oh
e
in
Pr
lif
ive
of
ct
n
fe
tio
ef
of
iva
pr
ck
de
La
1
1
ts
e
utt
lif
en
-o
o
m
m
g-
tt
ng
d g i ki n
gh
jju
rk
Ri
tr
er
er
/
/S
tth
ts
O
n
en
en
tts
iio
e
em n
at
tttl me
oll
v
vii
se
s e d gm
y
y
n
no
dl jju
ne
en
to
ng
ie
dii
Fr
Fr
as
as
lle
fiin
a
att
tts
en
en
n
ng
m
di n
s
gm
ts
dg
on
fiin io
ud
e
en
Ju
a
tts latt
o
gm
e n vi o
u
ud
fj
Ju
1959-2022
Albania
Andorra
Armenia
Austria
Azerbaijan
Belgium
Bosnia Herzegovina
Bulgaria
Croatia
Cyprus
Czech Republic
Denmark
Estonia
Finland
France
Georgia
Germany
Greece
Hungary
Iceland
Ireland
Italy
Latvia
Liechtenstein
This table has been generated automatically, using the conclusions recorded in the metadata for each judgment contained in HUDOC, the Court’s case-law database.
1. Other judgments: just satisfaction, revision, preliminary objections and lack of jurisdiction.
2. Figures in this column may include conditional violations.
3. Cases in which the Court held there would be a violation of Article 2 and/or 3 if the applicant was removed to a State where he/she was at risk. Figures in this column
are available only from 2013 onwards.
4. Including 94 judgments which concern 2 or more respondent States.
To
a
ta
ll n
um
g
dg
b
be
ro
m
m
Total
94
9
174
408
274
298
115
801
506
92
246
65
68
192
1,087
143
363
1,082
649
39
41
2,493
164
10
Total
78
4
163
286
263
211
108
723
406
76
197
22
49
142
785
118
202
969
612
27
25
1,915
130
8
Total
7
3
6
81
3
53
7
52
66
9
27
31
17
36
200
21
133
45
21
8
11
81
29
2
Total
2
1
Total
7
1
5
2
2
2
3
1
3
4
3
4
2/3
4
5
6
6
38
2
6
10
6
25
7
1
1
8
3
9
10
11
12
13
32
1
14
P1-1
32
1
2
37
4
47
1
67
144
55
4
15
1
1
2
P1-2
P1-3
P1-4
3
9
12
1
1
22
4
30
29
2
91
20
10
2
1
8
11
1
1
60
13
1
96
57
10
52
97
96
76
18
115
142
14
71
1
15
37
287
44
30
145
22
11
5
301
25
3
6
116
8
64
14
182
105
36
81
8
7
62
285
6
102
545
359
7
6
24
7
1
4
1
1
13
4
36
18
5
1
22
9
2
1
1
1
20
17
1
43
11
18
10
19
2
1
1
25
2
4
11
24
2
18
17
6
16
7
3
15
2
27
1
10
4
13
9
3
2
1
1
3
1
1
24
4
3
22
1
52
16
6
3
1
1
20
15
3
96
54
8
20
6
4
7
24
48
2
10
5
27
3
13
11
1
9
64
1
13
20
6
3
1
355
3
21
7
4
9
1
1
5
38
3
15
48
10
1
4
142
2
16
3
31
12
3
4
46
14
4
4
5
2
1
280
33
17
33
18
3
1
199
37
12
1
8
2
4
25
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
16
2
8
10
1
3
2
10
2
2
9
6
4
10
2
1
2
47
30
5
1
19
1
12
11
1
4
16
2
6
1
2
9
8
1
2
3
3
3
3
2
6
1
76
24
32
88
104
1
3
2
1
26
3
1
10
55
9
24
17
5
3
42
2
9
6
3
2
7
13
2
1
40
5
25
289
72
10
17
14
17
7
32
9
4
88
59
1
5
2
9
1
1
125
46
14
19
34
7
2
11
1
28
1
1
6
1
20
3
9
36
19
16
13
2
45
60
1
14
1,205
21
4
26
5
1
5
188
35
3
10
3
2
104
6
2
1
8
2
380
4
1
17
3
1
31
9
4
1
UUI, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Endeligt svar på spørgsmål 101: MFU spm. om ministeren kan redegøre for konsekvenserne for Danmark, hvis vi bliver dømt for overtrædelse af Den Europæiske Menneskerettighedskonvention (EMRK)? Kan ministeren i den forbindelse oplyse, hvilke andre lande har en dom imod sig? Der henvises til forhandlingerne under forespørgselsdebat F 8, den 30. november 2023.
2805428_0002.png
Violations by Article and by State
n
io
nt
ve
on
C
ice
e
tw
th
ed
of
sh
s
le
ni
tic
pu
Ar
or
er
ed
th
ns
tri
O
tio
be
ec
to
el
e
ot
fre
tn
n
o
gh
io
tt
Ri
at
gh
uc
Ri
ed
ty
o
tt
er
gh
op
Ri
pr
n
of
io
n
at
tio
in
ec
rim
ot
sc
Pr
y
di
ed
of
m
re
on
iti
ve
ib
cti
oh
fe
Pr
ef
an
n
ry
o
tio
ar
tt
m
cia
gh
o
so
Ri
tt
as
gh
d
Ri
an
y
bl
n
m
d
se
sio
as
es
an
e
pr
of
nc
ex
m
of
cie
do
ns
m
ily
ee
co
m
Fr
do
t,
fa
ee
gh
Fr
nd
ou n a
th igio te
of rel iva
pr
m
do
or
aw
tf
ee
tl
ec life
Fr
ou
sp
re
ith
o
tw
tt
en
gh
m
t
Ri
sh
en
ni
m
pu
ce
o
or
N
s
nf
ng
-e
di
on
ee
N
oc
pr
²
of
al
th
tri
ng
ir
Le
fa
y
a
rit
o
cu
tt
se
gh
d
ur
Ri
an
bo
ty
la
er
d
ce
lib
or
o
/f
tt
ry
gh
3
ve
Ri
sla
ns
of
tio
la
on
io
n
iti
lv
tio
ib
na
ga
oh
tio
Pr
sti
di
t
ve
in
on
en
C
m
ive
at
ct
fe
tre
ef
g
in
of
ad
ck
gr
²
La
de
re
rtu
or
to
an
n
of
m
tio
on
hu
ga
iti
In
sti
ib
ve
oh
e
in
Pr
lif
ive
of
ct
n
fe
tio
ef
of
iva
pr
ck
de
La
1
s
ts
e
ut
lif
e
en
-o
o
g-
tt
gm iing
k
gh
ud
rk
Ri
tr i
rj
er
/
/S
tth
tts
O
n
n
en
en tts
iio
n
e
e m en
at
tttl
o
oll
gm
v
vi
s
s e gm
ly j u d
ud
e
no
ne
nd
on
to
ng
ng
iie
di
Fr
as
le
fn
f in
at
ts
en
ng
ng
m
m
di n
s
n
tts
dg
dg
f
f in o
io
en
en
Ju
a
tts llatt
o
gm
e n vi o
u
ud
fj
u
Ju
1959-2022
Lithuania
Luxembourg
Malta
Republic of Moldova
Monaco
Montenegro
Netherlands
North Macedonia
Norway
Poland
Portugal
Romania
Russian Federation
San Marino
Serbia
Slovak Republic
Slovenia
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
Türkiye
Ukraine
United Kingdom
Sub-total
TOTA L
4
This table has been generated automatically, using the conclusions recorded in the metadata for each judgment contained in HUDOC, the Court’s case-law database.
1. Other judgments: just satisfaction, revision, preliminary objections and lack of jurisdiction.
2. Figures in this column may include conditional violations.
3. Cases in which the Court held there would be a violation of Article 2 and/or 3 if the applicant was removed to a State where he/she was at risk. Figures in this column
are available only from 2013 onwards.
4. Including 94 judgments which concern 2 or more respondent States.
To
To
tta
ln
um
um
dg
dg
be
ro
m
m
Total
250
52
138
575
4
71
177
191
72
1,254
373
1,754
3,500
22
244
422
377
206
157
223
3,900
1,840
567
Total
173
37
106
492
3
65
98
168
45
1,057
285
1,541
3,317
14
217
378
346
143
62
131
3,458
1,800
329
21,784
Total
58
12
20
44
1
4
51
15
27
137
23
91
121
5
19
13
24
56
62
84
100
23
146
2,085
Total
13
3
Total
6
2
3
2
6
1
3
3
33
3
10
2/3
1
4
5
26
1
6
36
17
13
180
3
10
32
57
12
130
42
481
1,076
10
33
53
27
67
28
39
991
622
97
5,703
6
28
17
14
13
6
2
7
1
8
23
4
9
2
10
3
3
5
5
21
11
1
1
12
13
8
3
27
14
7
1
4
7
P1-1
33
1
56
160
P1-2
P1-3
1
P1-4
1
1
12
5
34
1
4
17
9
4
114
65
1
27
121
1
1
41
2
1
7
45
2
3
1
12
18
63
2
16
3
12
5
2
1
4
2
1
3
4
10
6
3
6
34
30
8
66
2
452
144
152
209
3
54
224
264
16
12
8
609
549
30
6,144
673
6
5
17
2
7
4
6
1
38
31
4
20
1
7
11
3
11
2
1
13
6
1
106
20
426
22
15
1,067
418
1
1
2
117
11
4
10
1
4
1
40
139
6
128
1
2
5
5
2
11
1
3
2
7
1
15
1
1
16
1
14
17
1
5
10
23
42
56
48
18
2
1
22
4
3
28
5
219
4
69
1,143
18
9
74
44
1
7
9
3
4
5
3
123
13
23
770
630
7
2
14
363
9
6
59
419
2
67
4
15
1
318
7
4
6
55
170
4
4
127
18
118
395
1
43
43
29
820
5
2
43
33
59
48
511
700
1
1
3
7
9
5
10
2
89
380
1,190
99
291
45
1
125
1,494
1
21
180
3
3
3
3
1
1
1
143
14
2
2
225
78
20
984
188
31
22
2
1
1
7
6
21
1
4
2
348
383
17
3,135
10
6
6
14
5
1
229
131
1
1
1,081
90
13
2
7
13
62
6
5
2
22
843
649
70
4,903
80
2
3
1
1
1
70
39
6
2
1
59
1
4
18
28
12
22
10
27
140
116
78
1,892
18
41
267
2
3
2
283
480
35
3,115
2
4
3
5
1
8
20
10
46
357
87
22
9
2
6
1
2
1
1
4
1
1
718
382
4
3,810
18
7
15
6
2
37
82
2
47
529
2
116
8
25,674