Klima-, Energi- og Forsyningsudvalget 2023-24
KEF Alm.del Bilag 388
Offentligt
2898792_0001.png
Ref. Ares(2024)5945432 - 21/08/2024
Offentligt
EUROPEAN
COMMISSION
Brussels,
XXX
[…](2024) XXX
draft
COMMISSION IMPLEMENTING REGULATION (EU) …/...
of
XXX
amending Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 as regards updating the monitoring
and reporting of greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to Directive 2003/87/EC of the
European Parliament and of the Council
(Text with EEA relevance)
This draft has not been adopted or endorsed by the European Commission. Any views
expressed are the preliminary views of the Commission services and may not in any
circumstances be regarded as stating an official position of the Commission. The
information transmitted is intended only for the Member State or entity to which it is
addressed for discussions and may contain confidential and/or privileged material.
EN
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0002.png
COMMISSION IMPLEMENTING REGULATION (EU) …/...
of
XXX
amending Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 as regards updating the monitoring
and reporting of greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to Directive 2003/87/EC of the
European Parliament and of the Council
(Text with EEA relevance)
THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION,
Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,
Having regard to Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of
13 October 2003 establishing a system for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within
the Union and amending Council Directive 96/61/EC
1
, and in particular Article 14(1) and
Article 30f(5) thereof,
Whereas:
(1)
Directive 2003/87/EC establishing a system for greenhouse gas emission allowance
trading within the Union (EU ETS) was revised and amended by Directive (EU)
2023/959 of the European Parliament and of the Council
2
to align it with Regulation
(EU) 2021/1119 of the European Parliament and of the Council
3
setting a target of at
least 55 % net emission reductions by 2030 compared to 1990.
Following the amendment of Directive 2003/87/EC by Directive (EU) 2023/958 of the
European Parliament and of the Council
4
and Directive (EU) 2023/959, Commission
Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066
5
should be amended accordingly to
incorporate the necessary definitions and detailed arrangements for the monitoring and
reporting of emissions from renewable fuels of non-biological origin and recycled
OJ L 275, 25.10.2003, p. 32, ELI:
http://data.europa.eu/eli/dir/2003/87/oj.
Directive (EU) 2023/959 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 10 May 2023 amending
Directive 2003/87/EC establishing a system for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading within the
Union and Decision (EU) 2015/1814 concerning the establishment and operation of a market stability
reserve for the Union greenhouse gas emission trading system (OJ L 130, 16.5.2023, p. 134,
ELI:
http://data.europa.eu/eli/dir/2023/959/oj).
Regulation (EU) 2021/1119 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 June 2021 establishing
the framework for achieving climate neutrality and amending Regulations (EC) No 401/2009 and (EU)
2018/1999
(‘European
Climate
Law’)
(OJ
L
243,
9.7.2021,
p.
1–17,
ELI:
http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg/2021/1119/oj)
Directive (EU) 2023/958 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 10 May 2023 amending
Directive 2003/87/EC as regards aviation’s contribution to the Union’s economy-wide emission
reduction target and the appropriate implementation of a global market-based measure (OJ L 130,
16.5.2023, p. 115,
ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/dir/2023/958/oj).
Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 of 19 December 2018 on the monitoring and
reporting of greenhouse gas emissions pursuant to Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament
and of the Council and amending Commission Regulation (EU) No 601/2012 (OJ L 334, 31.12.2018, p.
1,
ELI: http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg_impl/2018/2066/oj).
(2)
1
2
3
4
5
EN
1
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0003.png
carbon fuels and also to ensure proper alignment with sustainability and greenhouse
gas savings criteria laid down in Directive (EU) 2018/2001 of the European
Parliament and of the Council
6
, for the monitoring and reporting of emissions from
the transport of CO
2
by other means than pipelines for geological storage, emissions
from aviation including monitoring and reporting of non-CO
2
aviation effects,
emissions from the new emission trading system for buildings, road transport and non-
ETS industry.
(3)
Under the new emission trading system for buildings, road transport and additional
sectors, it is necessary, for the definition of a ‘final consumer’ in Article 3(69) to
provide for more specific reference to the definition of regulated entity in Article 3(ae)
of Directive 2003/87/EC.
Article 5 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 should be amended to reflect
that the completeness of monitoring and reporting should cover all process and
combustion emissions of the stationary installation, from all emission sources and
source streams belonging to activities listed in Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC and
other directly associated activities in line with Article 3(e) of that Directive.
To improve the quality of information on biomass, on renewable fuels of non-
biological origin (RFNBOs), on recycled carbon fuels (RCFs), and on synthetic low-
carbon fuels and to facilitate national reporting under Regulation (EU) 2018/1999 of
the European Parliament and of the Council
7
, operators should monitor and report
emissions from the non-zero rated and zero-rated carbon fraction of these fuels as
memo-items in the emission reports. For that purpose, parameters concerning non-
zero-rated and zero-rated biomass, RFNBOs and RCFs, or synthetic low-carbon fuels
should be determined and reported for each corresponding source stream under the
standard calculation methodology pursuant to Article 24 of Implementing Regulation
(EU) 2018/2066 and the mass balance system pursuant to Article 25 of that
Regulation. Specific rules are necessary on the determination of composition-related
calculation factors concerning non-zero-rated and zero-rated biomass, RFNBOs and
RCFs, and synthetic low-carbon fuels, including the zero-rated and non-zero-rated
carbon fraction.
To avoid systematic underestimation of the total emissions in the mass balance system
when zero-rated carbon is contained in the input and in the output streams, it is
important for operators to determine the zero-rated carbon content of the output
streams. Clear evidence is required to demonstrate that underestimation has been
avoided and that the total mass of the zero-rated carbon fractions in the output
materials is equivalent to the total mass of zero-rated carbon fractions contained in the
input materials.
(4)
(5)
(6)
6
7
Directive (EU) 2018/2001 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 December 2018 on the
promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources (OJ L 328, 21.12.2018, p. 82,
ELI:
http://data.europa.eu/eli/dir/2018/2001/oj).
Regulation (EU) 2018/1999 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 December 2018 on the
Governance of the Energy Union and Climate Action, amending Regulations (EC) No 663/2009 and
(EC) No 715/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council, Directives 94/22/EC, 98/70/EC,
2009/31/EC, 2009/73/EC, 2010/31/EU, 2012/27/EU and 2013/30/EU of the European Parliament and
of the Council, Council Directives 2009/119/EC and (EU) 2015/652 and repealing Regulation (EU) No
525/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council, (OJ L 328, 21.12.2018, p. 1,
ELI:
http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg/2018/1999/oj).
EN
2
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0004.png
(7)
Directive 2003/87/EC, as revised by Directive (EU) 2023/959, specifies that the
emission factor of biomass is zero if the biomass complies with the sustainability and
greenhouse gas emissions savings criteria for the use of biomass fuels established by
Directive (EU) 2018/2001, taking into account any necessary adjustments for
application under Directive 2003/87/EC, as set out in the implementing acts referred to
in Article 14 of that Directive. In order to clarify the conditions under which biomass
emissions can be zero-rated and to align with the revised Directive 2018/2001, Article
38(5) of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 should be amended. Where the
relevant sustainability and greenhouse gas emissions savings criteria do not apply to a
specific type of biomass, that biomass can be zero-rated directly. However, in this
case, operators should still demonstrate that the criteria are not applicable. Assessing
the proof of applicability and proof of sustainability is an essential part of the
verification where the verifier checks the correct application of the monitoring
methodology, including the zero-rating of the biomass. Where sustainability and
greenhouse gas emissions savings criteria laid down in Article 29(2) to (7) and (10) do
apply, compliance with these criteria is required for zero-rating. Biomass that does not
comply with the criteria in this case should be treated as a fossil fuel. Zero-rating of
emissions under EU ETS is distinct from support schemes defined in Article 2, point
(5) of Directive (EU) 2018/2001.
Article 31a of Directive (EU) 2023/2413 of the European Parliament and of the
Council
8
sets up a Union database to enable the tracing of liquid and gaseous
renewable fuels, recycled carbon fuels and synthetic low-carbon fuels (‘the Union
Database’). By 21 November 2024, the Union Database should be fully operational.
Where compliance is required with the sustainability and the greenhouse gas
emissions saving criteria laid down in Article 29, paragraphs (2) to (7) and (10) of
Directive (EU) 2018/2001, for biomass, and Article 29a of that Directive, for liquid
and gaseous renewable fuels and RCFs, proof of sustainability should be provided in
line with Article 30 and 31 of that Directive. To facilitate this process and to reduce
the administrative burden, Member States should be able to rely on the evidence
provided by EU ETS operators, aircraft operators and regulated entities from the
Union Database on the transactions related to any amount of fuel that has been
purchased and used during the reporting year and that has been connected to the
cancellation of the respective quantity in the Union database. In the case of subsequent
non-compliance regarding the proof of sustainability of the quantities cancelled in the
databases, the competent authority shall correct the verified emissions accordingly.
According to Article 33 of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066, sampling is to
be representative for the specific batch and free of bias. Where continuous sampling of
the flue gas stream is used, the analysis frequency should be aligned with this process
and cover the whole reporting year without interruption.
Directive (EU) 2023/959 has extended the scope of activities listed in Annex I to
Directive 2003/87/EC for the refining of any oil, the production of any iron, the
production of alumina, the production of hydrogen and the transport of CO
2
through
means other than pipelines. In order to ensure alignment with Annex I to Directive
(8)
(9)
(10)
8
Directive (EU) 2023/2413 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 18 October 2023 amending
Directive (EU) 2018/2001, Regulation (EU) 2018/1999 and Directive 98/70/EC as regards the
promotion of energy from renewable sources, and repealing Council Directive (EU) 2015/652, (OJ L,
2023/2413, 31.10.2023, ELI:
http://data.europa.eu/eli/dir/2023/2413/oj).
EN
3
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0005.png
2003/87/EC, the Annexes to Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 need to be
updated.
(11)
Directive 2003/87/EC recognises the potential role of RCFs and RFNBOs for reducing
greenhouse gas emissions in sectors that are hard to decarbonise. To contribute to the
decarbonisation, their greenhouse gas emissions savings need to meet the minimum
greenhouse gas emissions savings laid out in Article 29a of Directive (EU) 2018/2001
and be calculated according to the methodology set out in the act adopted pursuant to
that Article.
RCFs or RFNBOs that contain carbon in their chemical composition, such as e-
kerosene or e-methanol, require a carbon feedstock for their production. Until all
stages of the life of a product, in which captured carbon is used, are subject to carbon
pricing, in particular at the stage of waste incineration, reliance on accounting for
emissions at the point of their release from products into the atmosphere would result
in emissions being underestimated. Where RFNBOs or RCFs are produced from
captured CO
2
under an activity covered by Directive 2003/87/EC, the emissions
should be accounted for under that activity. In order to avoid double counting and
requiring a double payment for the same emissions, the CO
2
emissions from RCFs and
RFNBOs that comply with the criteria laid out in Directive (EU) 2018/2001 should
have an emission factor of zero.
Synthetic low-carbon fuels must comply with the greenhouse gas savings criteria laid
down in Article 2 point 13 of Directive (EU) 2024/1788 on common rules for the
internal markets in renewable gas and natural gas and in hydrogen. Synthetic low-
carbon fuels require carbon feedstock for their production. Subject to review in respect
of zero-rated carbon combusted in installations which are exempt from the EU ETS
due their high use of biomass pursuant to point 1 of Annex I, to avoid double counting
within the EU ETS in accordance with Article 5 of Commission Implementing
Regulation (EU) 2018/2066, if the carbon content of the fuels stems from the EU ETS
and it has therefore been accounted, including when its emissions factor is zero, the
emissions from the synthetic low-carbon fuel should be zero-rated. The emissions
resulting from synthetic low-carbon fuels with other carbon content should be treated
as their fossil fuel equivalents. It is necessary to provide rules for the determination of
the fraction of zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fuels.
RCFs or RFNBOs that do not meet the greenhouse gas emissions savings laid out in
Article 29a of Directive 2018/2001 are considered to lead to insufficient greenhouse
gas emissions savings in comparison to fossil fuels. Therefore, the emissions resulting
from the combustion of such RCFs or RFNBOs should be treated as their fossil fuel
equivalents. As fossil fuels may be blended with RCFs or RFNBOs, it is necessary to
provide rules for the determination of the fraction of zero-rated RCF or RFNBO.
Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 should determine the monitoring
methodology that should be applied to emissions from zero-rated RFNBOs, RCFs and
synthetic low-carbon fuels. Provisions should be included for the deduction of total
zero-rated RFNBO, RCF and synthetic low-carbon fuels emissions, in the case where
the operator uses the measurement-based methodology for the determination of total
CO
2
emissions. When designing support schemes for renewable or low-carbon fuels,
Member States retain the right to specify how to incentivise the different RFNBOs,
RCFs or synthetic low carbon fuels. .
In addition, when applying the measurement-based methodology for biomass-
containing fuels and materials, conditions should be added when the biomass fraction
(12)
(13)
(14)
(15)
(16)
EN
4
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0006.png
equals the zero-rated biomass fraction. Clarifications should also be provided when
these conditions are not met and in such case the provisions deployed related to
calculation-based approach should be followed by the operator.
(17)
When the installation’s proposed methodology involves continuous sampling from the
flue gas stream, and at the same time the stationary installation consumes natural gas
from the grid, to avoid double counting, the CO
2
stemming from biogas should be
determined by laboratory analysis and this amount should be respectively deducted
from the total zero-rated CO
2
previously determined by calculation-based approach.
Directive 2003/87/EC does not recognise negative greenhouse gas emissions. To avoid
generating negative emissions, an operator should not subtract from its emissions any
CO
2
that originates from zero-rated fuels. In the case of the capture of emissions from
a mix of zero and non-zero-rated sources, to ensure clarity and simplicity, the quantity
of CO
2
resulting from non-zero-rated sources that can be deducted from the operator’s
emissions should be established based on the proportion of the zero-rated and non-
zero-rated emissions.
The activities ‘transport of greenhouse gases for geological storage’, and ‘geological
storage of greenhouse gases’, in Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC, cover all CO
2
transported and stored in a storage site permitted under Directive 2009/31/EC,
irrespective of the geographical and physical origin of the CO
2
. In order to avoid any
gaps in the monitoring and reporting framework and to provide the incentives for
operators of CO
2
transport infrastructure or of CO
2
storage sites to minimise leaks, it is
necessary to clarify that these operators should monitor and report any emissions from
all CO
2
for geological storage in their custody, including if originating from activities
outside of the scope of Directive 2003/87/EC.
As CO
2
for geological storage is expected to be transported by a variety of modes,
Directive (EU) 2023/959 expanded the scope of the activity ‘transport of greenhouse
gases for geological storage’ in Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC to any transport
mode. Therefore, it is necessary to revise the monitoring and reporting provisions
related to the CO
2
transport activity to ensure that they are applicable to a CO
2
transport infrastructure based on any transport modes. Where a transport mode is also
covered by another activity under Directive 2003/87/EC, to avoid the double counting
of emissions, the emissions covered by the other activity under that Directive should
be excluded from the boundaries of the CO
2
transport activity.
The transport of CO
2
for geological storage may take place over long distances.
Therefore, the CO
2
may be in transit for lengthy periods. In such cases, it is
appropriate to provide the operator of the CO
2
transport infrastructure the flexibility to
subtract from the emissions to be reported in a given year any amount of CO
2
that is
still in transit by 31 December of that year, provided that the CO
2
shipment reaches its
destination and is transferred out to a storage site or to another EU ETS installation no
later than 31 January of the following year.
The revised Directive 2003/87/EC amended the definition of emissions to also
encompass greenhouse gases that are not directly released into the atmosphere.
Therefore, these should also be considered emissions under the EU ETS, unless they
are stored in a storage site in accordance with Directive 2009/31/EC or they are
permanently chemically bound in a product so that they do not enter the atmosphere
under normal use, and do not enter the atmosphere under any normal activity taking
place after the end of the life of the product. In consequence, the Annexes to
Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 need to be updated accordingly to account
(18)
(19)
(20)
(21)
(22)
EN
5
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0007.png
for greenhouse gases released in ways other than directly into the atmosphere, while
avoiding the double counting of emissions where greenhouse gases not emitted
directly into the atmosphere are re-used within the same installation or in another EU
ETS installations. To avoid undue disruptions for installations affected by these
changes, their application should be delayed until 1 January 2025 to allow sufficient
time for the necessary adaptations.
(23)
When determining the oxidation or conversion factor of a source stream, carbon
monoxide (CO) emitted to the atmosphere should be considered as the molar
equivalent amount of CO
2
. CO that is otherwise transferred in a product or as a
feedstock is not considered as an emission under the scope of Directive 2003/87/EC.
Article 12(3b) of Directive 2003/87/EC provides that allowances do not need to be
surrendered for greenhouse gases which are considered to have been captured and
utilised in such a way that they have become permanently chemically bound in a
product so that they do not enter the atmosphere under normal use, including any
normal activity taking place after the end of the life of the product. It is necessary to
include a general provision for operators to determine and subtract from their
emissions the amount of CO
2
considered to be permanently chemically bound in a
product listed in the delegated act adopted pursuant to Article 12(3b) of Directive
2003/87/EC, replacing the provision that allowed to subtract the CO
2
considered
chemically bound in precipitated calcium carbonate.
Having regard to Article 14(5) of Directive 2003/87/EC, the monitoring, reporting and
verification framework (MRV) of non-CO
2
effects constitutes a stand-alone, distinct
exercise from carbon pricing. EU research and innovation activities on the impact and
technological solutions of non-CO
2
aviation effects are ongoing since 1994 and should
continue. Given the uncertainties surrounding the impacts of non-CO
2
effects, it is key
to start the MRV on non-CO
2
effects with a view to ensuring scientific validation of
the impacts.
Aircraft operators should monitor the non-CO
2
aviation effects occurring from 1
January 2025, from the activities performed by aeroplanes equipped with jet engines,
enabling the calculation of a CO
2
equivalent (CO
2
(e)) per flight. The aircraft operators
should report those non-CO
2
aviation effects once a year. However, to facilitate the
start of the MRV for non-CO
2
effects, in 2025 and 2026, while the reporting may
cover all routes, such reporting shall only be required in respect of routes involving
two aerodromes located in the European Economic Area (EEA), and routes from an
aerodrome located in the EEA departing to Switzerland or to the United Kingdom. In
respect of 2025 and 2026, the reporting of non-CO
2
aviation effects taking place from
other flights is possible.
In order to minimise administrative burden, aircraft operators should provide a single
monitoring plan for CO
2
emissions and non-CO
2
effects.
The calculation of the CO
2
(e) per flight should be done using the Global Warming
Potential (GWP) metric in three time horizons GWP
20
, GWP
50
and GWP
100
, to better
understand those impacts on climate, applying efficacy, as defined in Implementing
Regulation (EU) 2018/2066, and the Commission’s non-CO
2
aviation effects tracking
system (NEATS), to refine the GWP metric.
In order to calculate CO
2
(e) for non-CO
2
effects, the aircraft operators should use a
CO
2
(e) calculation approach. This approach includes modules for estimating fuel burn
and different emissions (NOx, CO, HC), models calculating CO
2
(e) using the input
(24)
(25)
(26)
(27)
(28)
(29)
EN
6
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0008.png
data and default values as described in Annex IIIa and Annex IIIb to Implementing
Regulation (EU) 2018/2066, where data gaps occur.
(30)
In order to avoid incentivizing underreporting, conservative default values may be
used. Where data sourced by the aircraft operator is not available, work needs to
continue to enable reporting of measured values, based on the best information
available. Relying on default values decreases the precision of the data.
Acknowledging the importance of providing appropriate tools to limit the
administrative effort of monitoring, reporting and verification of non-CO
2
aviation
effects, the aircraft operators may rely on the information technology tool, NEATS,
provided by the Commission. The aircraft operators may also opt to use their own or
third-party information technology tools provided that these tools comply with the
provisions of Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066, in particular Article 56a, and
provided that the Commission approves them.
The aircraft operators should securely collect, and store monitored data, including
flight details and aircraft information. For this purpose, the aircraft operators may rely
on the Commission IT tool and/or third-party resources, ensuring compliance with
confidentiality rules and accessibility for verification purposes.
In a situation where no data is provided by the aircraft operators NEATS should be
able to calculate the CO
2
(e) automatically, on the basis of data gathered from external
sources and the default values as described in Annex IIIa and Annex IIIb to
Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066.
In the event of the unavailability of IT tools, aircraft operators should monitor
essential flight and aircraft properties information as an interim measure.
In the event of the unavailability of common reference Numerical Weather Prediction
(NWP) model, aircraft operators should use a location-based simplified approach to
calculate the CO
2
(e) of non-CO
2
aviation effects as an interim measure.
For the purpose of minimising the administrative burden, small emitters may choose to
use a location-based simplified approach to calculate the CO
2
(e) of non-CO
2
aviation
effects.
Based on the feedback on the implementation of the EU ETS, it is necessary to further
facilitate the identification of the operator of an aircraft pursuant to Article 3(o) of
Directive 2003/87/EC and to include an additional step in this process.
In order to align the provisions of Article 28a(4) of Directive 2003/87/EC and this
Regulation concerning the definition of small emitters, this Regulation should be
updated to allow operators meeting the criteria defined in Article 28a(4) of that
Directive, to use the fuel estimation tools implemented by Eurocontrol.
Reporting requirements play a key role in ensuring proper emission monitoring and
enforcement of legislation. In order to streamline those reporting requirements,
appropriate reporting rules should be established for aircraft operators for the use of
different types of alternative aviation fuels, including biofuels, RFNBOs, RCFs and
other fuels eligible under the EU ETS support system established pursuant to Article
3c(6) of Directive 2003/87/EC.
Emission thresholds apply to aircraft operators for their inclusion into the EU ETS or
ICAO’s Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation
(CORSIA). Aircraft operators can be considered small emitters or allowed to use
simplified tools. In accordance with the purpose of the EU ETS and the principles also
(31)
(32)
(33)
(34)
(35)
(36)
(37)
(38)
(39)
(40)
EN
7
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0009.png
included in ICAO’s CORSIA scheme, the calculation of these emissions thresholds
should not take into account the possible use of fuels with an emission factor of zero.
Therefore, it is appropriate to establish a preliminary emission factor for the purpose
of a calculation of these thresholds.
(41)
In accordance with Directive (EU) 2023/959, the surrendering of allowances under the
new emissions trading for buildings, road transport and additional sectors system will
start in 2028 for the annual emissions of 2027. However, the monitoring and reporting
of emissions under the new emissions trading system will start from 1 January 2025.
Clear monitoring and reporting rules for the emissions trading system for buildings,
road transport and additional sectors should be laid down sufficiently in advance, in
order to facilitate orderly implementation in Member States. In order to reduce
administrative burden, to ensure consistency between monitoring methodologies and
to build on experiences from the existing emission trading system for stationary
installations and aviation, it is appropriate to set up the relevant rules for the new
system.
In order to ensure a robust level of monitoring accuracy and to minimise the
administrative burden for the regulated entities and competent authorities, the scope
factor should be applied after the categorisation of the regulated entity and the fuel
streams. This should allow more accurate monitoring and should avoid unnecessary
changes to the monitoring plans, which reduce the administrative burden for regulated
entities and competent authorities.
In order to limit the administrative burden, it is appropriate to provide specific rules
for regulated entities with low emissions and give flexibility to the competent
authorities in the categorisation of regulated entities.
In order to facilitate the implementation of the new measures, it is appropriate to
provide a time-bound derogation, before 2027, to the application of the scope factor
after the categorisation. It is appropriate for the competent authorities to be able to
qualify regulated entity as regulated entities with low emissions, or to allow the
regulated entity to classify itself and each fuel stream, based on the emissions after the
application of the scope factor, with the exclusion of CO
2
stemming from biomass,
where it can be demonstrated to the satisfaction of the competent authority that the
scope factor applied for the classification will also remain to be representative in the
future years.
In order to facilitate verification, it is appropriate that stationary installations operators,
aircraft operators, shipping companies and regulated entities submit the information on
fuels used for activities referred to in Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC together with
the annual emissions report. No separate report should be required on the amounts of
fuels acquired and used. Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 should therefore
be amended accordingly.
In order to facilitate the orderly and coherent submission of the monitoring plan for
regulated entities to the competent authorities, and considering the provisions that
have already been adopted in Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2023/2122
of 17 October 2023, amending Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066, all
provisions contained in this Regulation relating to the new emissions trading for
buildings, road transport and additional sectors, should apply from 1 July 2024.
Directive 2003/87/EC already provides that the emissions from RFNBOs used for
aircraft operators shall be zero-rated before the entry into force of this revision of the
(42)
(43)
(44)
(45)
(46)
(47)
EN
8
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0010.png
Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066. Therefore, in order to ensure consistency,
clarity and a level playing field, the rules for monitoring and reporting of emissions
from zero-rated RFNBO, RCF and synthetic low-carbon fuels should apply as of 1
January 2024.
(48)
The measures provided for in this Regulation are in accordance with the opinion of the
Climate Change Committee.
HAS ADOPTED THIS REGULATION:
Article 1
Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2066 is amended as follows:
(1)
Articles 1 and 2 are replaced by the following:
‘Article 1
This Regulation lays down rules for the following:
(i)
from 1 January 2021 and subsequent trading periods, monitoring and reporting
of greenhouse gas emissions and activity data pursuant to Directive
2003/87/EC in the trading period of the Union emissions trading system;
from 1 January 2025, monitoring and reporting of non-CO
2
aviation effects
pursuant to Article 14 of Directive 2003/87/EC.
Article 2
This Regulation shall apply to the monitoring and reporting of greenhouse gas emissions
specified in relation to the activities listed in Annex I and III to Directive 2003/87/EC, to
activity data from stationary installations, to aviation activities, including non-CO
2
aviation
effects, and to released fuel amounts from activities referred to in Annex III to that Directive.
It shall apply to the following:
(i)
(ii)
from 1 January 2021, emissions, activity data and released fuel amounts
occurring;
from 1 January 2025, non-CO2 aviation effects.
(ii)
The monitoring and reporting of non-CO
2
aviation effects from 2025 shall cover all non-CO
2
effects from aviation activities listed in Annex I to the Directive involving an aerodrome
located in the EEA. However, in respect of the monitoring and reporting of non-CO
2
aviation
effects taking place in 2025 and 2026, such reporting shall only be required in respect of
routes involving two aerodromes located in the EEA, and routes from an aerodrome located in
the EEA departing to Switzerland or to the United Kingdom. In respect of 2025 and 2026, the
non-CO
2
aviation effects taking place from other flights may be reported on a voluntary
basis.’;
(2)
(a)
Article 3 is amended as follows:
point (4)(b) is replaced by the following:
‘(b) in the case of a mass balance methodology in accordance with Article 25 of
this Regulation, one of the following:
(i)
a specific fuel type, raw material or product containing carbon;
9
EN
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0011.png
(ii)
(b)
CO2 transferred in accordance with Article 49 of this Regulation;’;
point (7) is replaced by the following:
‘ (7) ‘calculation factors’ means net calorific value, emission factor, preliminary emission
factor, oxidation factor, conversion factor, carbon content, fossil fraction, biomass fraction,
zero-rated biomass fraction, RFNBO or RCF fraction, zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction,
synthetic low-carbon fraction, zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction, zero-rated fraction,
or unit conversion factor;’,
(c)
point (15) is replaced by the following:
‘ (15) ‘conversion factor’ means the ratio of carbon emitted as CO
2
to the total carbon
contained in the source stream before the emitting process takes place, expressed as a
fraction, considering CO emitted to the atmosphere as the molar equivalent amount of
CO
2
. In the case of CO
2
emissions considered to be permanently chemically bound in a
product, conversion factor means the ratio of CO
2
bound as carbon in a product during the
production process in which the CO
2
is bound to the total CO
2
contained as carbon in a
product leaving the production process;’;
(d)
points (23b) to (23h) are inserted:
‘(23b) ‘alternative aviation fuels’ means neat aviation fuels containing carbon other
than stemming from the neat fossil fuels listed in Table 1 of Annex III to this
Regulation;
(23c) ‘zero-rating’ means the mechanism by which the emission factor of a fuel or
material is reduced in order to acknowledge:
(a)
in case of biomass, its compliance with sustainability or greenhouse gas
savings criteria provided by Article 29(2) to (7) and (10) of Directive
(EU) 2018/2001, as specified in Article 38(5) of this Regulation;
in case of RFNBO or RCF, its compliance with the greenhouse gas
savings criteria in accordance with Article 29a of Directive (EU)
2018/2001, as specified in Article 39a(3) of this Regulation;
in case of synthetic low-carbon fuels, its compliance with the
greenhouse gas savings criteria provided by Article 2 point 13 of
Directive (EU) 2024/1788 on common rules for the internal markets in
renewable gas and natural gas and in hydrogen ; and the prior
surrendering of allowances under Directive 2003/87/EC for the captured
carbon necessary to produce the synthetic low-carbon fuels, as specified
in Article 39a(4) of this Regulation, unless that captured carbon is zero-
rated carbon as defined in Article 3(38f).
(b)
(c)
(23d) ‘zero-rated fuels’ means biofuels, bioliquids, biomass fuels, synthetic low-
carbon fuels, RFNBO or RCF or fractions of mixed fuels or materials which comply
with the criteria as specified in Articles 38(5) or 39a(3) or 39a(4) of this Regulation, as
applicable;
(23e) ‘recycled carbon fuels’ (RCF) means recycled carbon fuels as defined in
Article 2, point (35) of Directive 2018/2011;
(23f) ‘renewable fuels of non-biological origin’ (RFNBO) means renewable fuels of
non-biological origin as defined in Article 2, point (36) of Directive 2018/2011;
EN
10
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0012.png
(23g) ‘neat fuel’ means a fuel in its pure form containing only one of the following
fractions:
(i)
(ii)
fossil fraction;
non-zero-rated biomass fraction;
(iii) zero-rated biomass fraction;
(iv) non-zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction;
(v)
zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction;
(vi) non-zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction;
(vii) zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction;
(viii) fraction of fuels containing carbon other than stemming from the fossil
fuels listed in Table 1 of Annex III to this Regulation or from biomass,
RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon fuels;
(23h) ‘synthetic low-carbon fuels’ means gaseous and liquid fuels, the energy
content of which is derived from low-carbon hydrogen as defined in Article 2, point
(13) of Directive (EU) 2024/1788, which meet the greenhouse gas emission reduction
threshold of 70% compared to the fossil fuel comparator for renewable fuels of non-
biological origin set out in the methodology adopted according to Article 29a(3) of
Directive (EU) 2018/2001, as certified in accordance with Article 9 of Directive (EU)
2024/1788.;’;
(e)
points (34) and (34a) are replaced by the following:
‘(34) ‘mixed fuel’ means a fuel which contains at least two of the following:
(i)
(ii)
carbon stemming from biomass;
carbon stemming from a RFNBO or RCF;
(iii) carbon stemming from synthetic low-carbon fuels;
(iv) other fossil carbon;
or which contains both zero-rated carbon and other carbon.
(34a) ‘mixed aviation fuel’ means a fuel which contains at least two different neat
fuels;’;
(f)
points (36), (37) and (38) are replaced by the following:
‘(36) ‘preliminary emission factor’ means the assumed total emission factor of a fuel
or material based on its total carbon content before multiplying it by the fossil fraction
to produce the emission factor;
(37) ‘fossil fraction’ means the ratio of fossil carbon to the total carbon content of a
fuel or material, expressed as a fraction;
(38) ‘biomass fraction’ means the ratio of carbon stemming from biomass to the
total carbon content of a fuel or material, expressed as a fraction, independent of
whether the biomass complies with the criteria of Article 38(5) of this Regulation;’;
(g)
(h)
point (38a) is deleted.
points (38b) to (38h) are inserted as follows:
EN
11
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0013.png
‘(38b) ‘zero-rated biomass fraction’ means the ratio of carbon stemming from biomass
which complies with the criteria of Article 38(5) of this Regulation to the total carbon
content of a fuel or material, expressed as a fraction;
(38c) ‘RFNBO or RCF fraction’ means the ratio of carbon stemming from an RFNBO
or RCF to the total carbon content of a fuel, expressed as a fraction, independent of
whether the RFNBO or RCF complies with the criteria of Article 39a(3) of this
Regulation;
(38d) ‘zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction’ means the ratio of carbon stemming from
an RFNBO or RCF that complies with the criteria of Article 39a(3) of this Regulation,
to the total carbon content of a fuel, expressed as a fraction;
(38e) ‘zero-rated carbon fraction’ means:
(i)
in case of a fuel, the sum of its zero-rated biomass fraction, its zero-rated
synthetic low-carbon fraction and its zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction
without double counting of any carbon;
in case of a material, its zero-rated biomass fraction.
(ii)
(38f) ‘zero-rated carbon’ means carbon contained in a fuel or material that belongs to
the zero-rated carbon fraction of that fuel or material.
(38g) ‘synthetic low-carbon fraction’ means the ratio of carbon stemming from
synthetic low-carbon fuel to the total carbon content of a fuel, expressed as a fraction,
independent of whether the synthetic low-carbon fuel complies with the criteria of
Article 39a(4) of this Regulation;
(38h) ‘zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction’ means the ratio of carbon stemming
from a synthetic low-carbon fuel that complies with the criteria of Article 39a(4) of
this Regulation, to the total carbon content of a fuel;’;
(i)
point (42) is replaced by the following:
‘(42) ‘fossil carbon’ means inorganic and organic carbon that is not zero-rated
carbon;’;
(j)
point (55) is replaced by the following:
‘(55) ‘CO
2
transport’ means the transport of CO
2
for geological storage in a storage
site permitted under Directive 2009/31/EC;’;
(k)
point (63) is replaced by the following:
‘(63) ‘CO
2
transport infrastructure’ means an infrastructure as defined in Article
3(29) of Regulation (EU) 2024/1735;’;
(l)
point (63b) is inserted:
‘(63b) ‘CO2 in transit’ means any amount of transferred CO2 in a CO2 transport
infrastructure that has not been transferred to another installation or CO2 transport
infrastructure within the same reporting period it was received;’;
(m)
point (69) is replaced by the following:
‘(69) ‘final consumer’ for the purposes of applying the definition of regulated entity,
in accordance with Article 3(ae) of Directive 2003/87/EC, in this Regulation, means
any natural or legal person that is the consumer of the fuel, whose annual fuel
consumption does not exceed 1 tonne of CO2;’;
EN
12
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0014.png
(n)
points (71) to (80) are inserted:
‘(71) ‘non-CO
2
aviation effects’ means non-CO
2
aviation effects as defined in Article
3(v) of Directive 2003/87/EC;
(72) ‘CO
2
(e) per flight’ means the non-CO
2
aviation effects that warm the
atmosphere, expressed as the equivalent amount of CO
2
emissions of the given
flight;
(73) ‘radiative forcing’ means an imposed change of the planetary energy balance,
measured in watts per square meter (W/m
2
);
(74) ‘efficacy’ is the change in global mean temperature per unit radiative forcing
exerted by the climate agent, relative to the response generated by a standard CO
2
forcing starting from the same initial climate state;
(75) ‘CO
2
(e) calculation model’ means a model used to calculate the total climate
impact of non-CO
2
aviation effects, in accordance with Annex IIIa Section 4 to this
Regulation;
(76) ‘weather-based approach’ means Method C, as provided in Annex IIIa Section
4 to this Regulation, using primarily enhanced weather data, as well as flight
information, trajectory, aircraft properties and fuel properties;
(77) ‘location-based simplified approach’ means Method D, as provided in Annex
IIIa Section 4 to this Regulation, using primarily aircraft in-flight location-related
data such as flight information, trajectory, but also basic weather data and aircraft
properties;
(78) ‘non-CO
2
aviation effects tracking system (NEATS)’ means an information
technology (IT) tool, that is provided by the Commission to aircraft operators, to
accredited verifiers and to competent authorities for the purpose of facilitating and, to
the extent possible, automating monitoring, reporting and verification of non-CO
2
aviation effects, in line with Article 14(5) of Directive 2003/87/EC;
(79) ‘aircraft properties’ means the category of information encompassing as a
minimum and for each flight, the aircraft type, the engine(s) identifier(s) and the
aircraft mass.
(80) ‘aeroplane’ means a power-driven heavier-than-air aircraft, which derives its
lift in flight chiefly from aerodynamic reactions on surfaces which remain fixed
under given conditions of flight.’;
(3)
Article 4 is replaced by the following:
Article 4
Operators and aircraft operators shall carry out their obligations related to the monitoring and
reporting of greenhouse gas emissions and non-CO
2
aviation effects under Directive
2003/87/EC in accordance with the principles laid down in Articles 5 to 9 of this Regulation.’;
(4)
in Article 5, the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘Monitoring and reporting shall be complete and cover all process and combustion emissions
from all emission sources and source streams belonging to activities listed in Annex I to
Directive 2003/87/EC and other relevant activities included pursuant to Article 24 of that
EN
13
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0015.png
Directive, as well as associated activities included in the boundaries of the installation, and of
all greenhouse gases specified in relation to those activities, while avoiding double-
counting.’;
(5)
in Article 6, paragraph 3 is inserted:
‘3. Aircraft operators shall obtain, record, compile, analyse and document monitoring data,
including assumptions, references, activity data and calculation factors, in a transparent
manner that enables the reproduction of the determination of non-CO2 aviation effects per
flight by the verifier and the competent authority.’;
(6)
Article 8 is replaced by the following:
Article 8
Operators and aircraft operators shall enable reasonable assurance of the integrity of emission
and non-CO2 aviation effects data to be reported. They shall determine emissions and non-
CO2 aviation effects using the appropriate monitoring methodologies set out in this
Regulation.
Reported emissions and non-CO2 aviation effects data and related disclosures shall be free
from material misstatement as defined in Article 3(6) of Commission Implementing
Regulation (EU) 2018/2067 (*), avoid bias in the selection and presentation of information,
and provide a credible and balanced account of an installation’s or aircraft operator’s
emissions and non-CO2 aviation effects.
In selecting a monitoring methodology, the improvements from greater accuracy shall be
balanced against additional costs. Monitoring and reporting shall aim for the highest
achievable accuracy, unless this is technically not feasible or incurs unreasonable costs.
(*) Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2018/2067 of 19 December 2018 on the verification of data and on the
accreditation of verifiers pursuant to Directive 2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council (OJ
L 334,
31.12.2018, p. 94,
ELI:
http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg_impl/2018/2067/oj).’;
(7)
in Article 11(1), the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘1. Each operator or aircraft operator shall monitor greenhouse gas emissions, and non-CO2
aviation effects, on the basis of a monitoring plan approved by the competent authority in
accordance with Article 12 of this Regulation, taking into account the nature and functioning
of the installation or aviation activity to which it applies.’;
(8)
(9)
(a)
in Article 14(2), the following point (aa) is inserted:
Article 15(4) is amended as follows:
the introductory sentence of paragraph (4) and the introductory sentence of point (a)
are replaced by the following:
‘4. Significant modifications to the monitoring plans of an aircraft operator include:
(a)
(b)
with regard to emissions:’;
point (a)(iv) is replaced by the following:
‘(aa) non-CO2 aviation effects occur due to new activities carried out;’;
‘(iv) changes in the status of the aircraft operator as a small emitter within the meaning of
Article 55(1) of this Regulation and whether the aircraft operator intends to use the
simplification pursuant to Article 28a(4) of Directive 2003/87/EC.’;
EN
14
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0016.png
(c)
point (b) is inserted:
‘(b) with regard to the non-CO
2
aviation effects:
(i)
(a change in the CO
2
(e) calculation approach selected, as laid down in Article
56a(4) of this Regulation, notably in terms of IT tools to apply the CO
2
(e)
calculation models;
changes in the status of the aircraft operator as a small emitter within the
meaning of Article 55(1) of this Regulation.’;
(ii)
(10)
in Article 18(2), second subparagraph, Article 19(2), points (a), (b) and (c), Article
19(5), Article 38(1) and Article 47(2), points (a) and (b), the term “biomass” is
replaced by “zero-rated carbon”.
in Article 19, paragraph 6 is deleted.
Article 24 is amended as follows:
paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
(11)
(12)
(a)
‘1. Under the standard methodology, the operator shall calculate combustion emissions of
each source stream by multiplying the activity data related to the amount of fuel
combusted, expressed as terajoules based on net calorific value (NCV), by the
corresponding emission factor, expressed as tonnes of CO
2
per terajoule (t CO
2
/TJ)
consistent with the use of NCV, and the corresponding oxidation factor.’;
(b)
the following paragraph 1a is inserted:
‘1a. For the purpose of reporting memo-items, the operator shall also calculate for each
source stream combusted and for fuels used as process input the following parameters
which are defined by these calculations:
(i)
the total preliminary emissions shall be calculated by multiplying the activity
data related to the amount of fuel combusted, expressed as tonnes or normal
cubic metres, by the corresponding preliminary emission factor and the
corresponding oxidation factor;
biomass emissions shall be calculated by multiplying the total preliminary
emissions by the biomass fraction;
(ii)
(iii) zero-rated biomass emissions shall be calculated by multiplying the total
preliminary emissions by the zero-rated biomass fraction;
(iv)
emissions from RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon fuels shall be
calculated by multiplying the total preliminary emissions by the RFNBO or
RCF fraction or the synthetic low-carbon fraction;
emissions from zero-rated RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon fuels shall be
calculated by multiplying the total preliminary emissions by the zero-rated
RFNBO or RCF fraction or the zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction;’;
(v)
(c)
the following paragraph 2a is inserted:
‘2a. For the purpose of reporting memo-items, the operator shall also calculate for each
source stream relating to process emissions the following parameters which are defined by
these calculations:
EN
15
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0017.png
(i)
The total preliminary emissions shall be calculated by multiplying the activity
data related to the material consumption, throughput or production output,
expressed in tonnes or normal cubic metres, by the corresponding emission
factor, expressed in t CO2/t or t CO2/Nm3, and the corresponding conversion
factor;
Biomass emissions shall be calculated by multiplying the total preliminary
emissions by the relevant biomass fraction;
(ii)
(iii) Zero-rated biomass emissions shall be calculated by multiplying the total
preliminary emissions by the relevant zero-rated biomass fraction.’;
(13)
(a)
Article 25 is amended as follows:
paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
‘(1) Under the mass balance methodology, the operator shall calculate the quantity of CO
2
corresponding to each source stream included in the mass balance by multiplying the activity
data related to the amount of fuel, material or CO2 transferred entering or leaving the
boundaries of the mass balance, with the fuel’s, material’s or CO2 transfer’s carbon content
multiplied by its fossil fraction and by 3,664 t CO2/t C, applying Section 3 of Annex II to this
Regulation.’;
(b)
the following paragraph 1a is inserted:
‘1a. For the purpose of reporting memo-items, the operator shall also calculate for each
source stream covered by the mass balance the following parameters which are defined by
these calculations:
(i)
The total preliminary quantity of CO2 shall be calculated by multiplying the
activity data related to the amount of fuel or material entering or leaving the
boundaries of the mass balance, with the fuel’s or material’s carbon content
and by 3,664 t CO2/t C;
The quantity of CO2 relating to biomass shall be calculated by multiplying the
total preliminary quantity of CO2 by the biomass fraction;
(ii)
(iii) The quantity of CO2 relating to zero-rated biomass shall be calculated by
multiplying the total preliminary quantity of CO2 by the zero-rated biomass
fraction;
(iv) If applicable, the quantity of CO2 relating to RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-
carbon fuels shall be calculated by multiplying the total preliminary quantity of
CO2 by the RFNBO or RCF fraction or the synthetic low-carbon fraction;
(v)
If applicable, the quantity of CO2 relating to zero-rated RFNBO, RCF or
synthetic low-carbon fuels shall be calculated by multiplying the total
preliminary quantity of CO2 by the zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction or the
zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction.’;
(c)
the following paragraph 3 is inserted:
‘3. Where the operator uses a mass balance in accordance with this Article, and zero-rated
carbon is contained in input materials or fuels, and output materials contain carbon, the
operator shall provide to the competent authority data on the zero-rated fraction of the carbon
content of the output streams. The operator shall thereby provide evidence that the
installation’s total emissions are not systematically underestimated by the applied monitoring
methodology and that the total mass of carbon corresponding to the zero-rated carbon
EN
16
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0018.png
fractions of the carbon contained in all relevant output materials, is not lower than the total
mass of zero-rated fractions of the carbon contained in input materials and fuels.
For the purpose of the first subparagraph, Article 39, paragraphs 3 and 4 shall apply regarding
the zero-rated biomass fraction of biogas and natural gas used as input.’;
(14)
(a)
(b)
Article 30 is amended as follows:
in paragraph 2, the last subparagraph is deleted.
the following paragraphs 2a and 3 are inserted:
‘2a. The operator shall determine the biomass fraction only for mixed fuels or materials
containing biomass. For other fuels or materials, the default value of 0% for the biomass
fraction of fossil fuels or materials shall be used, and a default value of 100% biomass
fraction for biomass fuels or materials consisting exclusively of biomass.
The operator shall determine the RFNBO or RCF fraction or the synthetic low-carbon fraction
only for mixed fuels containing RFNBOs, RCFs or synthetic low-carbon fuels. For other fuels
the default value of 0% for the RFNBO or RCF fraction or the synthetic low-carbon fraction
shall be used, and a default value of 100% RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon
fraction for fuels consisting exclusively of RFNBOs, RCFs or synthetic low-carbon fuels.
The operator shall determine the zero-rated biomass fraction, zero-rated RFNBO or RCF
fraction and zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction only where the operator wants to make
use of zero-rating.
3. Regarding the interdependency of composition-related calculation factors, the operator
shall apply the following rules:
(i)
(ii)
Where a fuel or material contains biomass, the operator shall determine the
biomass fraction in accordance with Article 39 of this Regulation.
Where the biomass fraction is not zero and where the operator wants to make
use of zero-rating, the operator shall determine the zero-rated biomass fraction
in accordance with Article 38(5) of this Regulation.
(iii) Where a fuel contains an RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon fuel, the
operator shall determine the RFNBO or RCF fraction or the synthetic low-
carbon fraction in accordance with Article 39a(1) and (2) of this Regulation.
(iv) Where the RFNBO or RCF fraction is not zero and where the operator wants to
make use of zero-rating, the operator shall determine the zero-rated RFNBO or
RCF fraction in accordance with Article 39a(3) of this Regulation.
(v)
Where the synthetic low-carbon fraction is not zero and where the operator
wants to make use of zero-rating, the operator shall determine the zero-rated
synthetic low-carbon fraction in accordance with Article 39a(4) of this
Regulation.
(vi) Where the zero-rated biomass fraction, the zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction
or the zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction are not zero, the operator shall
calculate the zero-rated fraction as the sum of zero-rated biomass fraction,
zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction and zero-rated synthetic low-carbon
fraction. The fossil fraction is the sum of all non-zero-rated fractions.
(vii) The operator shall calculate the emission factor as the preliminary emission
factor multiplied by the fossil fraction.
EN
17
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0019.png
For the purpose of point (vi), where the operator does not calculate the zero-rated fraction, the
fossil fraction shall be 100%.
By way of derogation from the first subparagraph, the operator may:
(i)
determine the biomass fraction as identical to the zero-rated biomass fraction,
if the latter is determined based on the mass balance pursuant to Article 30(1)
of Directive (EU) 2018/2001;
determine the RFNBO or RCF fraction as identical to the zero-rated RFNBO or
RCF fraction, if the latter is determined based on the mass balance pursuant to
Article 30(1) of Directive (EU) 2018/2001;
(ii)
(iii) determine the synthetic low-carbon fraction as identical to the zero-rated
synthetic low-carbon fraction, if the latter is determined based on the mass
balance pursuant to Article 30(1) of Directive (EU) 2018/2001.’;
(15)
in Article 37(2), the last subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘Where mixed fuels are used, the operator shall provide evidence that application of points (a)
or (b) of the first subparagraph does not lead to an underestimation of emissions.’;
(16)
(17)
(a)
(b)
(c)
in Section 2, the title of subsection 5 is replaced by the following:
Article 38 is amended as follows:
in paragraph 1, the last subparagraph is deleted;
in paragraph 2, the first subparagraph is deleted;
paragraph 4 is amended as follows:
(i)
(ii)
(d)
(i)
the term ‘biomass fraction’ is replaced by ‘zero-rated biomass’;
the last subparagraph is deleted;
the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘T
REATMENT OF BIOMASS
,
SYNTHETIC LOW
-
CARBON FUELS
, RFNBO
AND
RCF’;
paragraph 5 is amended as follows:
‘Biofuels, bioliquids and biomass fuels shall fulfil the sustainability and the greenhouse gas
emissions saving criteria laid down in paragraphs 2 to 7 and 10 of Article 29 of Directive
(EU) 2018/2001, in order to be counted towards the zero-rated biomass fraction of a source
stream.’;
(ii)
the sixth subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘The compliance with the criteria laid down in paragraphs 2 to 7 and 10 of Article 29 of
Directive (EU) 2018/2001 shall be assessed in accordance with Articles 30 and 31(1) of that
Directive. The criteria may also be considered complied with if the operator provides
evidence for a purchase of a quantity of biofuel, bioliquid or biogas connected to the
cancellation of the respective quantity in the Union Database set up pursuant to Article 31a or
a national database set up by the Member State in accordance with Article 31a(5) of that
Directive. In case of subsequent non-compliance regarding the proof of sustainability of the
quantities cancelled in the aforementioned databases, the competent authority shall correct the
verified emissions accordingly.’;
(iii) the seventh subparagraph is replaced by the following:
EN
18
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0020.png
‘Where the biomass used does not comply with this paragraph, its carbon content shall be
considered as fossil carbon.’;
(iv) the following eighth subparagraph is inserted:
‘Where according to the first to sixth subparagraphs of this paragraph, the criteria laid down
in paragraphs 2 to 7 and 10 of Article 29 of Directive (EU) 2018/2001 do not apply to
biomass, the zero-rated biomass fraction equals its biomass fraction.’;
(18)
(a)
Article 39 is amended as follows:
paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
‘1. For fuels or materials containing biomass, the operator may either assume the absence of
biomass and apply a default biomass fraction of 0 % or determine a biomass fraction in
accordance with paragraph 2, applying tiers as defined in Section 2.4 of Annex II to this
Regulation.’;
(b)
in paragraph 2, the second subparagraph is replaced the following:
‘Where, subject to the tier level required, the operator has to carry out analyses to determine
the biomass fraction, but the application of the first subparagraph is technically not feasible or
would incur unreasonable costs, the operator shall submit an alternative estimation method to
determine the biomass fraction to the competent authority for approval. For fuels or materials
originating from a production process with defined and traceable input streams, the operator
may base the estimation on a material balance of fossil and biomass carbon entering and
leaving the process.’;
(c)
(d)
paragraph 2a is deleted.
paragraph 3 is amended as follows:
(i)
(ii)
in the first subparagraph, the reference to “Article 43(4)” is replaced by
“Article 43(4b)”.
the second subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘The operator may determine that a certain quantity of natural gas from the gas grid is zero-
rated biogas by using the methodology set out in paragraph 4. In this case, by way of
derogation from Article 30(3), the operator shall consider the biomass fraction to be identical
to the zero-rated biomass fraction.’;
(e)
paragraph 4 is amended as follows:
(i)
the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘4. The operator may determine the biomass fraction and identical zero-rated
biomass fraction of biogas using purchase records of biogas of equivalent energy
content, provided that the operator provides evidence to the satisfaction of the
competent authority that:’;
(ii)
the last subparagraph is replaced by:
‘For the purpose of demonstrating compliance with this paragraph, the operator may
use the data recorded in a database set up by one or more Member States which
enables tracing of transfers of biogas. Compliance with this paragraph may be
considered demonstrated if the operator provides evidence for a purchase of a
quantity of biogas connected to the cancellation of the respective quantity in the
Union Database set up pursuant to Article 31a of Directive (EU) 2018/2001 or a
national database set up by the Member States in accordance with Article 31a(5) of
EN
19
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0021.png
that Directive. In case of subsequent non-compliance regarding the proof of
sustainability of the quantities cancelled in the aforementioned databases, the
competent authority shall correct the verified emissions accordingly.’;
(19)
the following Article 39a is inserted:
‘Article
39a
Determination of RFNBO or RCF or synthetic low-carbon fraction and zero-rated
RFNBO or RCF or synthetic low-carbon fraction
1.
For fuels or materials containing RFNBOs, RCFs or synthetic low-carbon fuels for
which the operator cannot determine the RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-
carbon fraction in accordance with paragraph 2, the operator shall assume the
absence of RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon fuel and apply a default RFNBO
or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction of 0 %.
The operator shall determine the following calculation factors relating to the
composition of fuels based on the mass balance pursuant to Article 30(1) of Directive
(EU) 2018/2001:
(i)
(ii)
the zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction or zero-rated synthetic low-carbon
fraction;
the RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction.
2.
By way of derogation from the first subparagraph, if the operator does not want to
make use of zero-rating, for the RFNBO or RCF fraction or the synthetic low-carbon
fraction other approaches may be used such as a material balance of the blending or
production process from which the fuel or material is obtained.
3.
The carbon content of fuels qualifying as RFNBOs or RCFs under Directive (EU)
2018/2001 that comply with the greenhouse gas emissions saving criteria laid down
in Article 29a of that Directive, shall be considered zero-rated.
The compliance with the criteria laid down in Article 29a of Directive (EU)
2018/2001 is to be assessed in accordance with Articles 30 and 31(1) of that
Directive. The criteria may also be considered complied with if the operator provides
evidence for a purchase of a quantity of RFNBOs or RCFs connected to the
cancellation of the respective quantity in the Union Database set up pursuant to
Article 31a of Directive (EU) 2018/2001, or a national database set up by the
Member States in accordance with Article 31a(5) of that Directive. In case of
subsequent non-compliance regarding the proof of sustainability of the quantities
cancelled in the aforementioned databases, the Competent Authority shall correct the
verified emissions accordingly.
Where the RFNBO or RCF does not comply with the criteria referred to in the first
subparagraph, its carbon content shall be considered as fossil carbon.
4.
Synthetic low-carbon fuels shall be zero-rated when their carbon content has been
subject to the prior surrendering of allowances under Directive 2003/87/EC, unless
that captured carbon is zero-rated carbon as defined in Article 3(38f).
The compliance with the criteria laid down in Article 29a(3) of Directive (EU)
2018/2001 is to be assessed in accordance with Articles 30 and 31(1) of that
EN
20
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0022.png
Directive. The criteria may also be considered complied with if the operator provides
evidence for a purchase of a quantity of synthetic low-carbon fuels connected to the
cancellation of the respective quantity in the Union Database set up pursuant to
Article 31a of Directive (EU) 2018/2001, or a national database set up by the
Member State in accordance with Article 31a(5) of that Directive. In case of
subsequent non-compliance regarding the proof of sustainability of the quantities
cancelled in the aforementioned databases, the Competent Authority shall correct the
verified emissions accordingly.
In any other cases, the carbon content of synthetic low-carbon fuels shall be
considered as fossil carbon.
5.
The operator may determine the RFNBO or RCF fraction and identical zero-rated
RFNBO or RCF fraction of natural gas where such fractions have been injected into
a natural gas grid using purchase records of RFNBO or RCF of equivalent energy
content, provided that the operator provides evidence to the satisfaction of the
competent authority that:
(a) there is no double counting of the same RFNBO or RCF quantity, in
particular that the RFNBO or RCF purchased is not claimed to be used by
anyone else, including through a disclosure of a guarantee of origin as defined
in Article 2(12) of Directive (EU) 2018/2001;
(b) the operator and the producer of the RFNBO or RCF are connected to the
same gas grid.
Compliance with this paragraph may be considered demonstrated if the operator provides
evidence for a purchase of a quantity of gaseous RFNBO or RCF connected to the
cancellation of the respective quantity in the Union Database set up pursuant to Article 31a of
Directive (EU) 2018/2001, or a national database set up by the Member States in accordance
with Article 31a(5) of that Directive. In case of subsequent non-compliance regarding the proof
of sustainability of the quantities cancelled in the aforementioned databases, the competent
authority shall correct the verified emissions accordingly.’;
(20)
(a)
Article 43 is amended as follows:
paragraph 4 is amended as follows:
(i)
the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘4. Where relevant, the operator shall determine separately any CO2 amount stemming
from biomass. For this purpose, the operator may use:’;
(ii)
the last subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘Where the method proposed by the operator involves continuous sampling from the flue gas
stream, EN 15259 (Air quality — Measurement of stationary source emissions —
Requirements for measurement sections and sites and for the measurement objective, plan and
report) shall be applied. The sampling plan pursuant to Article 33 shall be commensurate with
the frequency of analysis in accordance with Annex VII to this Regulation and ensure
representativeness to cover the whole reporting year.’;
(b)
the following paragraphs 4a, 4b and 4c are inserted:
‘4a. The operator shall use the biomass fraction determined in accordance with paragraph 4
as the zero-rated biomass fraction, if the following conditions are fulfilled for all fuels or
materials leading to emissions to which the measurement-based methodology is applied:
EN
21
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0023.png
(i)
according to the first to sixth subparagraphs of Article 38(5) of this Regulation,
the criteria laid down in paragraphs 2 to 7 and 10 of Article 29 of Directive
(EU) 2018/2001 do not apply; or
100% of the biomass fraction of the used fuel or material are covered by the
evidence relevant according to Article 38(5) of this Regulation.
(ii)
The condition (ii) shall be deemed fulfilled for biogas monitored in accordance with Article
39(4) of this Regulation.
Where conditions (i) and (ii) are not fulfilled for fuels or materials leading to emissions to
which the measurement-based methodology is applied, the operator shall determine the zero-
rated biomass fraction for these fuels or materials using a calculation-based approach in
accordance with Articles 24 to 39a of this Regulation.
4b. The operator may deduct from the total emissions of the emission source the emissions
from zero-rated biomass determined in accordance with paragraph 4a of this Article.
Where the method proposed by the operator for the determination of the zero-rated biomass
fraction involves continuous sampling from the flue gas stream and the installation consumes
natural gas from the grid, the operator shall determine the physical CO
2
amount of the biogas
used in accordance with Articles 32 to 35 of this Regulation and deduct the respective CO
2
amount from the zero-rated CO
2
determined in accordance with paragraph 4a of this Article.
4c. Where the operator uses zero-rated RFNBOs, RCFs or synthetic low-carbon fuels in a
process for which the measurement-based methodology is applied, the operator may deduct
from the total emissions the emissions from zero-rated RFNBOs, RCFs or synthetic low-
carbon fuels.
The emissions from zero-rated RFNBOs, RCFs or synthetic low-carbon fuels shall be
determined using a calculation-based approach in accordance with Articles 24 to 39a of this
Regulation. They shall equal the activity data of the relevant fuel multiplied by the
preliminary emission factor and the zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction or the zero-rated
synthetic low-carbon fraction.’;
(c)
in paragraph 5, point (a) is replaced by the following:
‘(a) calculation by means of a suitable material balance, taking into account all significant
parameters on the input side, including for CO
2
emissions at least input material loads, input
airflow and process efficiency, and on the output side, including at least the product output
and the concentration of oxygen (O
2
), sulphur dioxide (SO
2
) and nitrogen oxides (NO
x
)’;
(21)
in Article 44(1), the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘1. The operator shall calculate hourly averages for each parameter, including concentrations
and flow, relevant for determining emissions or amounts of CO
2
transferred, using a
measurement-based methodology by using all data points available for that specific hour.’;
(22)
(23)
(24)
(a)
in Article 46 and in Annex I, Section 1, points (7)(a), (b) and (c), the term “transport
network” is replaced by “CO
2
transport infrastructure”.
in Article 47(2), the last subparagraph is deleted.
Article 48 is amended as follows:
in paragraph 2, the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘2. Where inherent CO
2
originates from activities covered by Annex I to
Directive 2003/87/EC or included pursuant to Article 24 of that Directive and is subsequently
transferred out of the installation as part of a source stream to another installation and activity
EN
22
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0024.png
covered by that Directive, it shall not be counted as emissions of the installation where it
originates. For the determination of the zero-rated biomass fraction, zero-rated RFNBO or
RCF fraction or zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction of the inherent CO
2
in accordance
with Article 39 of this Regulation, the operator of the transferring installation shall ensure the
chosen monitoring methodology does not systematically underestimate the transferring
installation’s total emissions.’;
(b)
in paragraph 3, the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘3. The operators may determine quantities of inherent CO
2
transferred out of the installation
both at the transferring and at the receiving installation. In that case, the quantities of
respectively transferred and received inherent CO
2
and the corresponding zero-rated biomass
fraction, zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction and zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction
shall be identical.’;
(25)
(a)
Article 49 is amended as follows:
paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
‘1. The operator shall subtract from the emissions of the installation any amount of CO2
originating from the activities covered by Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC that does not
originate from zero-rated carbon and that is not emitted from the installation, but transferred
out of the installation to any of the following installations:
(i)
(ii)
a capture installation for the purpose of transport and long-term geological
storage in a storage site permitted under Directive 2009/31/EC;
a CO2 transport infrastructure with the purpose of long-term geological storage
in a storage site permitted under Directive 2009/31/EC;
(iii) a storage site permitted under Directive 2009/31/EC for the purpose of long-
term geological storage.’;
(b)
paragraphs 3 and 4 are replaced by the following:
‘3. For the determination of the quantity of CO
2
transferred from one installation or CO
2
transport infrastructure to another installation or CO
2
transport infrastructure in accordance
with paragraph 1, the operator shall apply, subject to the further provisions set out in Annex
IV to this Regulation, either a calculation-based methodology, or a measurement-based
methodology, in accordance with Articles 43, 44 and 45 of this Regulation.
Where the measurement-based methodology is applied the emission source shall correspond
to the measurement point and the emissions shall be expressed as the quantity of CO
2
transferred.
4. When using a measurement-based methodology for determining the quantity of CO
2
transferred from one installation or CO
2
transport infrastructure to another, the operator shall
apply the highest tier as defined in Section 1 of Annex VIII to this Regulation.
However, the operator may apply the next lower tier provided that it establishes that applying
the highest tier as defined in Section 1 of Annex VIII to this Regulation is technically not
feasible or incurs unreasonable costs.’;
(c)
paragraphs 6 and 7 are inserted:
‘6. In the case of the transfer of CO
2
to a capture installation resulting from materials or fuels
containing a fraction of zero-rated carbon, the transferring installation shall only subtract from
its reported emissions in accordance with the first paragraph of this Article the quantity of
CO
2
proportional to the fraction of carbon that does not originate from zero-rated carbon.
EN
23
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0025.png
An operator of a CO
2
transport infrastructure or a storage site shall monitor emissions from
leakage events, fugitive emissions and vented emissions from any CO
2
mentioned in the first
sub-paragraph, including from CO
2
stemming from entities not carrying out activities listed in
Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC, and report emissions as if the CO
2
were fossil.
7. The operator of a CO
2
transport infrastructure may include in the emissions reported in a
given reporting period, any CO
2
in transit that has been transferred to another installation or
CO
2
transport infrastructure no later than 31 January of the following year. The operator shall
compile annually an inventory of the CO
2
entering and leaving the CO
2
transport
infrastructure and report separately any CO
2
in transit.’;
(26)
the following Article 49a is inserted:
‘Article 49a
Emissions permanently chemically bound in a product
1.
The operator shall subtract from the emissions of the installation any amount of CO
2
originating from non-zero-rated
carbon in activities covered by Annex I to
Directive 2003/87/EC that is not emitted from the installation, but permanently chemically
bound in a product listed in the Delegated Regulation adopted pursuant to Article 12(3b) of
Directive 2003/87/EC.
In the case of CO
2
resulting from materials or fuels containing a fraction of zero-rated carbon,
the operator shall only subtract from the emissions of the installation the quantity of CO
2
permanently chemically bound in a product listed in the Delegated Regulation adopted
pursuant to Article 12(3b) of Directive 2003/87/EC proportional to the fraction of carbon that
does not originate from zero-rated carbon.
2.
For the determination of the quantity of CO
2
bound in a product meeting the
specifications set out in paragraph 1, the operator shall either apply the standard methodology
in accordance with Sections 2 and 4 of Annex II to this Regulation, or apply a mass balance in
accordance with Article 25 of this Regulation using the fuels and materials entering and
leaving the process in which the CO
2
is chemically bound as the relevant source streams for
this calculation, while taking into account any combustion emissions related to the process.
To this end, the highest tier as defined in Annex II to this Regulation shall be applied as
specified in the same Annex for the activity the CO
2
arises from. However, the operator may
apply the next lower tier provided that the operator demonstrates to the satisfaction of the
competent authority that applying the highest tier as defined in Annex II to this Regulation is
technically not feasible or incurs unreasonable costs.’;
(27)
(28)
(a)
the title to Chapter IV is replaced by the following:
Article 51 is amended as follows:
in paragraph 1, the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘MONITORING OF EMISSIONS AND NON-CO
2
EFFECTS FROM AVIATION’;
‘1. Each aircraft operator shall monitor and report emissions and non-CO
2
aviation effects
from aviation activities for all flights included in Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC that are
EN
24
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0026.png
performed by that aircraft operator during the reporting period and for which the aircraft
operator is responsible.’;
(b)
Paragraph 3 is replaced by the following:
‘3. For the purpose of identifying the unique aircraft operator referred to in point (o) of Article
3 of Directive 2003/87/EC that is responsible for a flight, the call sign used for air traffic
control purposes as laid down in item 7 of the flight plan, shall be used. The call sign shall
determine the aircraft operator as follows:
(a)
where the item 7 contains the ICAO designator for the aircraft operating
agency, the unique aircraft operator shall be the aircraft operating agency that
has been assigned that ICAO designator;
where the item 7 contains the nationality or common mark, and registration
mark of the aircraft that is explicitly listed in an air operator certificate (or
equivalent) or in a document issued by a State and identifying the operator of
the aircraft, then the unique aircraft operator shall be the legal or natural person
that holds that air operator certificate (or equivalent) or that is stated in the
document.’;
(b)
(c)
the following paragraph 3a is inserted:
‘ 3a. Where the unique aircraft operator cannot be identified using the call sign as referred to
in paragraph 3, the unique aircraft operator referred to in point (o) of Article 3 of Directive
2003/87/EC that is responsible for a flight, is the legal or natural person that has an
employment or other contractual relationship with the captain of the flight.’;
(29)
In Article 52(1), the first two subparagraphs are replaced by the following:
‘1. At the latest four months before an aircraft operator commences aviation activities covered
by Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC, it shall submit to the competent authority a monitoring
plan for the monitoring and reporting of emissions and non-CO
2
aviation effects in
accordance with Article 12 of this Regulation.
By way of derogation from the first subparagraph, an aircraft operator that performs an
aviation activity covered by Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC, or monitors and reports non-
CO
2
aviation effects, for the first time that could not be foreseen four months in advance of
the activity shall submit a monitoring plan to the competent authority without undue delay,
but no later than six weeks after performance of that activity. The aircraft operator shall
provide adequate justification to the competent authority why a monitoring plan could not be
submitted four months in advance of the activity.’;
(30)
(a)
Article 53 is amended as follows:
paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
‘1. Each aircraft operator shall determine the annual CO
2
emissions from aviation activities
by multiplying the annual consumption of each neat fuel (expressed in tonnes) by the
respective emission factor.
For mixed aviation fuels, the aircraft operator shall determine the theoretical amount of
each neat fuel from the total amount of that mixed aviation fuel and relevant composition
data by applying the following:
(i)
where a fuel contains biomass, the aircraft operator shall determine the
biomass fraction in accordance with Article 54;
EN
25
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0027.png
(ii)
where a fuel contains an RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon fuel, the
aircraft operator shall determine the RFNBO or RCF fraction or the synthetic
low-carbon fraction in accordance with Article 54b;
(iii) where the RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction is not zero
and where the aircraft operator wants to make use of zero-rating, the aircraft
operator shall determine the zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction or the zero-
rated synthetic low-carbon fraction in accordance with Article 54c;
(iv) where the zero-rated biomass fraction, the zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction
or the zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction are not zero, the aircraft
operator shall calculate the zero-rated fraction as the sum of zero-rated biomass
fraction, zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction and zero-rated synthetic low-
carbon fraction. The fossil fraction is the sum of all non-zero-rated fractions.
(v)
the aircraft operator shall calculate the amount of each neat fuel as total amount
of the mixed aviation fuel multiplied by the relevant fraction.’;
For the purpose of point (iv) of this paragraph, where the aircraft operator does not calculate
the zero-rated fraction, the fossil fraction shall be 100%.
(b)
the following paragraphs 1a and 1b are inserted:
‘1a. By way of derogation from paragraph 1, for the purpose of assessing emissions
thresholds set out in Articles 55(1) and 55(2) of this Regulation, in Article 28a(4) of Directive
2003/87/EC and in the entry ‘Aviation’ of the table in Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC, the
aircraft operator shall determine the CO
2
emissions by multiplying the annual consumption of
each fuel by its preliminary emissions factor.
1b. For the purpose of reporting pursuant to Article 3 of Commission Delegated Regulation
(EU) 2019/1603 (
*
), the aircraft operator shall determine and report the emissions which result
from multiplying the annual consumption of each fuel by its preliminary emission factor.
(*)
Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/1603 of 18 July 2019 supplementing Directive
2003/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards measures adopted by the
International Civil Aviation Organisation for the monitoring, reporting and verification of aviation
emissions for the purpose of implementing a global market-based measure (OJ L 250, 30.9.2019, p. 10,
ELI:
http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg_del/2019/1603/oj
). ’;
(c)
in paragraph 6, the last subparagraph is replaced by:
‘For alternative aviation fuels other than biofuels, RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon
fuels, the aircraft operator shall determine the emission factor in accordance with Article
32 of this Regulation. For such fuels, the net calorific value shall be determined and
reported as a memo-item.’
(31)
the following Article 53a is inserted:
‘Article 53a
Reporting rules for the use of alternative aviation fuels
1.
2.
The aircraft operator shall monitor the amount of alternative aviation fuels used and
report that amount as attributed to each flight or aerodrome pair.
Where the alternative aviation fuels are delivered to the aircraft in physically
identifiable batches, the aircraft operator shall provide evidence to the satisfaction of
the competent authority that the alternative aviation fuel is attributed to the flight
immediately following the fuel uplift of that flight.
EN
26
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0028.png
Where several subsequent flights are carried out without fuel uplift between these
flights, the aircraft operator shall split the amount of the alternative fuel and assign it
to these flights proportionally to the emissions from those flights calculated using the
preliminary emission factor.
3.
Where alternative aviation fuels cannot be physically attributed at an aerodrome to a
specific flight, the aircraft operator shall attribute the fuel to its flights for which
allowances have to be surrendered in accordance with Article 12(3) of Directive
2003/87/EC proportionally to the emissions from those flights departing from that
aerodrome calculated using the preliminary emission factor.
In this regard, the aircraft operator must provide evidence to the satisfaction of the
competent authority that the alternative aviation fuel was delivered to the fuelling
system of the departure aerodrome in the reporting period, or 3 months before the
start, or 3 months after the end, of that reporting period.
4.
For the purpose of paragraphs 2 and 3, the aircraft operator shall provide evidence to
the satisfaction of the competent authority that:
(i)
the total amount of alternative aviation fuel claimed does not exceed the total
fuel usage of that aircraft operator for flights for which allowances have to be
surrendered in accordance with Article 12(3) of Directive 2003/87/EC,
originating from the aerodrome at which the alternative aviation fuel is
supplied;
the amount of alternative aviation fuel for flights for which allowances have to
be surrendered in accordance with Article 12(3) of Directive 2003/87/EC does
not exceed the total quantity of alternative aviation fuel purchased from which
the total quantity of alternative aviation fuels sold to third parties is subtracted;
(ii)
(iii) the ratio between alternative aviation fuels and fossil fuels attributed to flights
aggregated per aerodrome pair does not exceed the maximum blending limit
for that fuel type as certified according to a recognised international standard;
(iv) there is no double counting of the same quantity of alternative aviation fuel, in
particular that the alternative aviation fuel purchased is not claimed to be used
in an earlier report or by another aircraft operator, or in another carbon pricing
system.
For the purpose of points (i) to (iii), any fuel remaining in tanks after a flight and before an
uplift is assumed to be 100 % fossil fuel.
For the purpose of demonstrating compliance with the requirements referred to under point
(iv) , the aircraft operator may use the data recorded in the Union database set up in
accordance with Article 31a of Directive (EU) 2018/2001 or a national database set up by the
Member State in accordance with Article 31a(5) of that Directive.’;
(32)
Articles 54 and 54a are replaced by the following:
‘Article 54
Determining the biomass fraction for biofuels
1.
The aircraft operator shall determine the biomass fraction of mixed aviation fuels
containing biofuels. The aircraft operator may either assume the absence of biofuel
and apply a default fossil fraction of 100% or determine a biofuel fraction in
EN
27
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0029.png
accordance with paragraphs 2 or 3. The aircraft operator shall use a default value of
100% biomass fraction for neat biofuels.
By way of derogation from the first subparagraph, the aircraft operator using mixed
aviation fuels containing biofuels may choose to monitor the biofuel content and
fossil aviation fuel content as separate source streams if the evidence provided by the
fuel suppliers allows such approach.
2.
Where biofuels are physically mixed with fossil fuels and delivered to the aircraft in
physically identifiable batches, the aircraft operator may carry out analyses in
accordance with Articles 32 to 35 to determine the biomass fraction, on the basis of a
relevant standard and the analytical methods set out in those Articles, provided that
the use of that standard and those analytical methods is approved by the competent
authority. Where the aircraft operator provides evidence to the competent authority
that such analyses would incur unreasonable costs or are technically not feasible, the
aircraft operator may base the estimation of the biofuel content on a material balance
of blending fossil fuels and biofuels purchased. If the biomass fraction was
determined using the mass balance pursuant to Article 30(1) of Directive (EU)
2018/2001, no evidence for unreasonable costs or technical feasibility shall be
required.
Where purchased biofuel batches are not physically delivered to a specific aircraft,
the aircraft operator shall not use analyses to determine the biomass fraction of the
fuels used. The aircraft operator may determine the biomass fraction using purchase
records of biofuel of equivalent energy content.
Article 54a
Specific provisions for eligible aviation fuels
1.
For the purpose of Article 3c(6) of Directive 2003/87/EC, the commercial aircraft
operator shall establish, document, implement and maintain a written procedure in
order to monitor any amounts of neat eligible aviation fuel (in tonnes) used for
subsonic flights, and shall report the amounts of eligible aviation fuels claimed as a
separate memo-item in its annual emission report.
For the purpose of paragraph 1, the aircraft operator shall ensure that any amount of
eligible aviation fuel claimed is certified in accordance with Article 30 of Directive
(EU) 2018/2001 or another certification accepted under Regulation 2023/2405. The
competent authority may allow the aircraft operator to use the data recorded in the
Union database set up in accordance with Article 31a of Directive (EU) 2018/2001 or
a national database set up by the Member State in accordance with Article 31a(5) of
that Directive. In case of subsequent non-compliance regarding the proof of
sustainability of the quantities cancelled in the aforementioned databases, the
Competent Authority shall correct the verified amounts of neat eligible aviation fuels
accordingly.
For mixed aviation fuels, the aircraft operator may either assume the absence of
eligible aviation fuel and apply a default fossil fraction of 100% or determine the
amount of neat eligible aviation fuel in accordance with paragraph 3a.
3a. The aircraft operator shall determine the amount of neat eligible aviation fuel as a
sum of neat alternative fuels eligible under Article 3c(6) of Directive 2003/87/EC as
3.
2.
3.
EN
28
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0030.png
determined in accordance with Article 53(1) of this Regulation. The neat eligible
fuels shall be attributed to each flight or aerodrome pair in accordance with
paragraphs 4 or 5.
4.
Where eligible aviation fuels are delivered to the aircraft in physically identifiable
batches, the aircraft operator shall provide evidence to the satisfaction of the
competent authority that the eligible aviation fuel is attributed to the flight
immediately following the fuel uplift of that flight.
Where several subsequent flights are carried out without fuel uplift between these
flights, the aircraft operator shall split the amount of the eligible aviation fuels and
assign it to these flights proportionally to the emissions from those flights calculated
using the preliminary emission factor.
5.
Where eligible aviation fuels cannot be physically attributed at an aerodrome to a
specific flight, the aircraft operator shall attribute the fuel to its flights for which
allowances have to be surrendered in accordance with Article 12(3) of Directive
2003/87/EC and to its flights covered by Article 3c(8) of that Directive
proportionally to the emissions from those flights departing from that aerodrome
calculated using the preliminary emission factor.
For that purpose, the aircraft operator must provide evidence to the satisfaction of the
competent authority that the eligible aviation fuel was delivered to the fuelling
system of the departure aerodrome in the reporting period, or 3 months before the
start, or 3 months after the end, of that reporting period.
6.
For the purpose of paragraphs 4 and 5, the aircraft operator shall provide evidence to
the satisfaction of the competent authority that:
(a)
the total amount of eligible aviation fuel claimed does not exceed the total fuel
usage of that aircraft operator for flights for which allowances have to be
surrendered in accordance with Article 12(3) of Directive 2003/87/EC and for
flights covered by Article 3c(8) of that Directive, originating from the
aerodrome at which the eligible aviation fuel is supplied;
the amount of eligible aviation fuel for flights for which allowances have to be
surrendered in accordance with Article 12(3) of Directive 2003/87/EC and
from flights covered by Article 3c(8) of that Directive does not exceed the total
quantity of eligible aviation fuel purchased from which the total quantity of
eligible aviation fuels sold to third parties is subtracted;
the ratio between eligible aviation fuels and fossil fuels attributed to flights
aggregated per aerodrome pair does not exceed the maximum blending limit
for that fuel type as certified according to a recognised international standard;
there is no double counting of the same quantity of eligible aviation fuel, in
particular that the eligible aviation fuel purchased is not claimed to be used in
an earlier report or by another aircraft operator, or in another carbon pricing
system.
(b)
(c)
(d)
For the purpose of points (a), (b) and (c), any fuel remaining in tanks after a flight and before
an uplift is assumed to be 100% not eligible fuel.
For the purpose of demonstrating compliance with the requirements referred to under point
(d), the aircraft operator may use the data recorded in the Union database set up in accordance
with Article 31a of Directive (EU) 2018/2001 or a national database set up by the Member
State in accordance with Article 31a(5) of that Directive.’;
EN
29
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0031.png
(33)
the following Articles 54b and 54c are inserted:
‘Article 54b
Determining the RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon fraction
1.
The aircraft operator shall determine the RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-
carbon fraction of mixed aviation fuels containing RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-
carbon fuel. The aircraft operator may either assume the absence of RFNBO, RCF
or synthetic low-carbon fuel and apply a default fossil fraction of 100 %, or
determine a RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction in accordance
with paragraphs 2 or 3. The aircraft operator shall use a default value of 100%
RFNBO or RCF fraction, or 100% synthetic low-carbon fraction, as applicable, for
neat RFNBO or RCF or neat synthetic low-carbon fuel.
By way of derogation from the first subparagraph, the aircraft operator using mixed
aviation fuels containing RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon fuel, may choose to
monitor the RFNBO or RCF content or synthetic low-carbon content and other fossil
aviation fuel content, as separate source streams if the evidence provided by the fuel
suppliers allows such approach.
2.
Where RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon fuel are physically mixed with fossil
fuels and delivered to the aircraft in physically identifiable batches, the aircraft
operator shall base the estimation of the RFNBO or RCF content or synthetic low-
carbon content on a mass balance pursuant to Article 30(1) of Directive (EU)
2018/2001, reflecting the blending of fossil fuels and RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-
carbon fuel purchased.
Where purchased RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon fuel batches are not
physically delivered to a specific aircraft, the aircraft operator may determine the
RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction using purchase records of
RFNBO, RCF or synthetic low-carbon fuel of equivalent energy content.
Article 54c
Conditions for zero-rating biofuels, RFNBO, RCF and synthetic low-carbon fuels by
aircraft operators
3.
1.
The aircraft operator may count the biomass fraction of a mixed aviation fuel
towards the zero-rated biomass fraction only to the extent that the biofuel content
complies with the criteria set out in Article 38(5).
The aircraft operator may count the RFNBO or RCF fraction of a mixed aviation fuel
towards the zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction only to the extent that the RFNBO or
RCF content complies with the criteria set out in Article 39a(3).
The aircraft operator may count the synthetic low-carbon fraction of a mixed aviation
fuel towards the zero–rated synthetic low-carbon fraction only to the extent that the
synthetic low-carbon content complies with the criteria set out in Article 39a(4).
The aircraft operator may claim zero-rated biofuels, zero-rated RFNBO or RCF and
zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fuels only to the extent these zero-rated fuels comply
with the maximum amount of fuel use determined in accordance with Article 53a of
2.
3.
4.
EN
30
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0032.png
this Regulation, for flights for which allowances have to be surrendered in
accordance with Article 12(3) of Directive 2003/87/EC.’;
(34)
in Article 55(2), the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘2. By way of derogation from Article 53, small emitters and aircraft operators
having total annual emissions lower than 3 000 tonnes of CO
2
from flights other than
those referred to in Article 28a(1), point (a), and Article 3c(8) of Directive
2003/87/EC may estimate the fuel consumption based on distance per aerodrome pair
using tools implemented by Eurocontrol or another relevant organisation, which can
process all relevant air traffic information and avoid any underestimations of
emissions.’;
(35)
the following Articles 56a and 56b are inserted:
‘Article 56a
Calculation of CO
2
equivalent for non-CO
2
aviation effects
1.
Each aircraft operator shall monitor the non-CO
2
aviation effects from its activities
performed by aeroplanes equipped with jet engines in CO
2
equivalent (CO
2
(e)) per
flight.
The aircraft operator shall calculate the CO
2
(e) per flight using the GWP metric, in
particular GWP
20
, GWP
50
and GWP
100
, resulting in three GWP values for each of the
monitored flights.
The aircraft operator shall use efficacy as defined in this Regulation and in NEATS,
to refine the GWP as referred to in paragraph 2 for calculating the CO
2
(e) per flight
unless the aircraft operator provides evidence to the competent authority that it is not
possible to use efficacy.
To calculate CO
2
(e) per flight each aircraft operator shall apply a CO
2
(e) calculation
approach covering the following elements:
(a)
(b)
the fuel-burn module and emissions-estimation module, as described in
Annex IIIa, Section 3;
Method C consisting of a weather-based approach and Method D
consisting of a location-based simplified approach, as referred to in
Annex IIIa, Section 4;
a default values approach, used in case of data gaps, described in Annex
IIIa, Section 5 and Annex IIIb.
2.
3.
4.
(c)
Method C and method D shall be based on input data from the modules referred to in point (a)
of this paragraph, data from the aircraft operator and relevant weather data from the aircraft
operator or third party-sources.
5.
6.
7.
Each aircraft operator shall use Method C to calculate CO
2
(e) per flight.
By way of derogation from paragraph 5, small emitters, as defined in Article 55(1),
may use Method D.
To apply the CO
2
(e) calculation models to their flights, aircraft operators shall meet
all the following conditions, either using NEATS, pursuant to Annex IIIa, Section 2,
own and third-party IT tools, or a combination of NEATS and these tools:
31
EN
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0033.png
(a)
these tools comply with the requirements laid down in Annex IIIa, with
regard to emission-estimation module in Section 3, 4 and 5 of that Annex;
(b)
where enhanced weather data is needed as defined in Annex IIIa, these
tools use the same common reference Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP)
model and weather data, as the one provided through NEATS;
(c)
these tools allow for and facilitate, for the purpose of verification,
access to the monitored data in accordance with Annex IIIa, Section 4;
(d)
these tools ensure the data monitored is securely stored for at least 2
years, with backup and recovery functions;
(e)
8.
these tools comply with the principles established by Article 75(1).
Where an aircraft operator plans to use tools referred to in paragraph 7, other than the
fuel burn module, the aircraft operator shall first submit the technical specifications
of the tools to the Commission. The Commission shall assess the specifications of
the tools and, where these tools comply with the requirements in this Regulation,
shall approve the tools. Once approved, the tools technical specifications and
workflow shall be further described by the aircraft operator in the monitoring plan.
Article 56b
Data monitoring
1.
2.
The aircraft operator shall monitor the data mentioned in Annex IIIa, Section 4.
The data monitored as referred to in paragraph 1 shall be sourced by the aircraft
operator, including from flight data recorder equipment of the aircraft, where
available.
By way of derogation from paragraph 2, the aircraft operator can choose to rely for
the monitoring of some or all of the data, on the following:
(a) independent third-party sources such as Eurocontrol;
(b) NEATS, as described in Annex IIIa, Section 2.
3.
4.
Where data is missing and the aircraft operator has demonstrated that it is not
capable of retrieving that data via NEATS or other methods, the aircraft operator
shall use default values as provided in Annex IIIa, Section 5 and Annex IIIb.
The aircraft operators shall provide the verifier with access to all data that is
necessary for the verification, including confidential data. Upon request of the
aircraft operator the competent authority shall treat information provided by the
aircraft operator as confidential.
Where it is not possible to use NEATS due to its unavailability, the aircraft operator
shall monitor at a minimum the flight information and aircraft properties per flight.
In such case the CO2(e) calculation per flight shall be performed at a later stage by
5.
6.
EN
32
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0034.png
the aircraft operator, at the latest, once NEATS is made available by the
Commission.
7.
Where it is not possible to use a common reference NWP model due to its
unavailability in NEATS, the aircraft operator, shall, by way of derogation from
Article 56a(5), use Method D. Once the common reference NWP model is made
available, the aircraft operator shall use the appropriate method in line with Article
56a(5) and (6).
NEATS shall be updated as appropriate’;
Article 58 is amended as follows:
paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
‘1. The operator or aircraft operator shall establish, document, implement and
maintain written procedures for data flow activities for the monitoring and reporting
of greenhouse gas emissions and non-CO
2
aviation effects and ensure that the annual
emissions report resulting from data flow activities does not contain misstatements
and is in conformance with the monitoring plan, those written procedures and this
Regulation.’;
(b)
in paragraph 2, point (c) is replaced by the following:
‘(c) each step in the data flow from primary data to annual emissions and non-CO
2
aviation effects which shall reflect the sequence and interaction between the data
flow activities, including relevant formulas and data aggregation steps applied’;
(37)
(a)
(b)
Article 66 is amended as follows:
the title is replaced by the following:
in paragraph 2, the last subparagraph is replaced by:
8.
(36)
(a)
‘Treatment of data gaps for emissions reporting’;
‘Where the number of flights with data gaps referred to in the first two sub-paragraphs exceed
5% of the annual flights that are reported, the aircraft operator shall inform the competent
authority thereof without undue delay and shall take remedial action for improving the
monitoring methodology.’;
(38)
in Article 68, the following paragraphs 5 and 6 are inserted:
‘5. The aircraft operator shall submit to the competent authority under the same conditions as
referred to in paragraph 1, a separate report as attachment to the annual emissions report, that
covers the annual non-CO
2
aviation effects.
6. The separate report referred to in paragraph 5 shall contain at least the information listed in
Annex X, Section 2a.’;
(39)
in Article 69(1), the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘1. Each operator shall regularly check whether the monitoring methodology applied can be
improved.’;
(40)
(a)
Article 70 is amended as follows:
in paragraph 1, the first subparagraph is replaced by the following:
EN
33
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0035.png
‘1. The competent authority shall make a conservative estimate of the emissions of an
installation or aircraft operator and, where relevant, the non-CO
2
aviation effects of an aircraft
operator in any of the following situations:’;
(b)
paragraph 2 is replaced by the following:
‘2. Where a verifier has stated, in the verification report pursuant to Implementing Regulation
(EU) 2018/2067, the existence of non-material misstatements which have not been corrected
by the operator or aircraft operator before issuing the verification report, the competent
authority shall assess those misstatements, and make a conservative estimate of the emissions
and non-CO
2
aviation effects of the installation or aircraft operator where appropriate. The
competent authority shall inform the operator or aircraft operator whether and which
corrections are required to the annual emissions report. The operator or aircraft operator shall
make that information available to the verifier.’;
(41)
Article 72(1) is replaced by the following:
‘1. Total annual emissions of each of the greenhouse gases CO
2
, N
2
O and PFCs, as well as
non-CO
2
aviation effects shall be reported as rounded tonnes of CO
2
or CO
2
(e). The total
annual emissions of the installation shall be calculated as the sum of the rounded values for
CO
2
, N
2
O and PFCs.’;
(42)
(43)
(a)
in Article 75d(3), second and third subparagraph and in Annex I, first Section, point
(4), subpoint (g), the term ‘biomass’ is replaced by ‘zero-rated fuels’.
Article 75e is amended as follows:
in paragraph 2, points (a) and (b) are replaced by the following:
(a)
‘a category A entity, where from 2027 to 2030 the average verified
annual emissions in the 2 years preceding the reporting period before the
application of the scope factor, with the exclusion of CO
2
stemming from
zero-rated fuels, are equal to or less than 50 000 tonnes of CO
2
(e);
a category B entity, where from 2027 to 2030 the average verified annual
emissions in the 2 years preceding the reporting period before the
application of the scope factor, with the exclusion of CO
2
stemming from
zero-rated fuels, are more than 50 000 tonnes of CO
2
(e).’;
(b)
(b)
in paragraph 3, point (a) is replaced by the following:
‘(a)
de minimis
fuel streams, where the fuel streams selected by the regulated entity
jointly account for less than 1 000 tonnes of fossil CO
2
per year before the
application of the scope factor;’;
(c)
paragraph 4 is replaced by the following:
‘4. Where the average annual verified emissions used to determine category of the
regulated entity as referred to in paragraph 2 are not available or no longer
representative for the purpose of paragraph 2, the regulated entity shall use a
conservative estimate of annual average emissions calculated before the application
of the scope factor, with the exclusion of CO
2
stemming from zero-rated fuels, to
determine the category of the regulated entity.’;
(d)
the following paragraph 4a is inserted:
‘4a. By way of derogation from paragraphs 2, 3 and 4, before 2027, the competent
authority may allow the regulated entity to classify itself and each fuel stream based
on the emissions after the application of the scope factor, with the exclusion of CO2
EN
34
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0036.png
stemming from zero-rated fuels, where the regulated entity can demonstrate to the
satisfaction of the competent authority that the scope factor applied for the
classification will remain to be representative in the future years.’;
(e)
(44)
(45)
(a)
paragraph 5 is deleted.
The title of subsection 4 is replaced by the following:
Article 75m is amended as follows:
the title and first paragraph, introductory sentence, are replaced by the following:
‘Article 75m
Release of fuel streams containing biomass, synthetic low-carbon fuels, RFNBO
and RCF
1. Article 38, Article 39, paragraphs 1, 3 and 4, and Article 39a shall apply. For that
purpose:’;
(b)
(46)
(a)
in paragraph 3 , the term ‘biomass fraction’ is replaced by ‘zero-rated carbon
fraction’.
Article 75n is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
‘T
REATMENT OF BIOMASS SYNTHETIC LOW
-
CARBON FUELS
, RFNBO
AND
RCF’;
‘1. The competent authority may consider a regulated entity to be a regulated entity with low
emissions where at least one of the following conditions is met:
(a) from 2027 to 2030, the average verified annual emissions in the 2 years preceding
the reporting period before the application of the scope factor, with the exclusion of
CO
2
stemming from zero-rated fuels, were less than 1 000 tonnes of CO
2
per year;
(b) from 2031, the average annual emissions of that regulated entity reported in the
verified emissions reports during the trading period immediately preceding the
current trading period, calculated before the application of the scope factor and with
the exclusion of CO
2
stemming from zero-rated fuels, were less than 1 000 tonnes of
CO
2
per year;
(c) where the average annual emissions referred to in point (a) are not available or no
longer representative for the purpose of point (a), but the annual emissions of that
regulated entity for the next 5 years, calculated before the application of the scope
factor and with the exclusion of CO
2
stemming from zero-rated fuels, will be, based
on a conservative estimation method, less than 1 000 tonnes of CO
2
(e) per year.’;
(b)
the following paragraph 1a is inserted:
‘1a. By way of derogation from paragraph 1, before 2027, the competent authority
may consider a regulated entity to be a regulated entity with low emissions based on
the emissions after the application of the scope factor, with the exclusion of CO
2
stemming from zero-rated fuels, where the regulated entity can demonstrate to the
satisfaction of the competent authority that the scope factor applied for the
classification will remain to be representative in the future years.’;
(47)
Annex I is amended as follows:
EN
35
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0037.png
(a)
Section 1 is amended as follows:
(i)
in point (7), point (f) is replaced by the following:
‘(f) where applicable, a description of the conservative estimation method used for
determining the zero-rated fraction and zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction of
inherent or transferred CO
2
in accordance with Articles 48, 49 or 49a;’;
(ii)
point (8) is replaced by the following:
‘8. a detailed description of the monitoring methodology where CO
2
is chemically
bound in accordance with Article 49a, where appropriate in the form of a description
of the written procedures applied, including the following:
(a)
the procedures for determining whether or not a product in which the CO2 is
permanently chemically bound in accordance with Article 49a(1) of this
Regulation, meets the requirements set out in the delegated Regulation
pursuant to Article 12(3b) of Directive 2003/87/EC and the types of uses of
those products;
a description of the calculation methodology for determining the CO2 amounts
permanently chemically bound in accordance with Article 49a(2).
‘9. where applicable, a description of the procedure used to assess if zero-rated
source streams comply with Article 38(5) or 39a(3) or 39a(4);
9a. where applicable, a description of the procedure used to determine zero-rated biogas
quantities based on purchase records in accordance with Article 39(4), or zero-rated
RFNBO or RCF quantities in accordance with Article 39a(5);’;
(b)
(iii) the following points (9) and (9a) are inserted:
(b)
Section 2 is amended as follows:
(i) point (1) is amended as follows:
- point (c) is replaced by the following:
‘(c) a description of procedures, systems and responsibilities used to update the completeness
of the list of emission sources over the monitoring year for the purpose of ensuring the
completeness of monitoring and reporting of the emissions and non-CO
2
aviation effects of
owned aircraft as well as leased-in aircraft;’;
- points (k), (l) and (m) are replaced by the following:
‘(k) confirmation if the aircraft operator intends to use any of the tools referred to in Article
55(2) of this Regulation and whether the aircraft operator intends to use the simplification
pursuant to Article 28a(4) of Directive 2003/87/EC;
(l) where applicable, a description of the procedure used to assess if zero-rated biofuel,
RFNBO, RCF, or synthetic low-carbon fuel comply with Article 54c of this Regulation;
(m) where applicable, a description of the procedure used to determine quantities of
alternative aviation fuels in accordance with Article 53(1) and to ensure the reported neat
fuels comply with the conditions set out in Article 53a of this Regulation;’;
- point (o), is replaced by the following:
‘(o) where applicable a description of the procedure used to determine eligible aviation fuel
quantities in accordance with Article 54a(3) and to ensure the reported fuels comply with the
conditions set out in Article 54a(4) and 54a(5) of this Regulation;’;
EN
36
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0038.png
– the following points (p) and (q) are inserted:
‘(p) a confirmation on whether the aircraft operator operates any flights under Article 56a(1);
(q) a confirmation on whether the aircraft operator intends to use only NEATS to determine
the non-CO
2
aviation effects, or if it intends to use, for all or part of the monitored data, own
or third party IT tools as described in Article 56a(7);’;
(ii) in point (2), the introductory sentence is replaced by:
‘2. For the purpose of monitoring emissions, the monitoring plan shall contain the following
information for aircraft operators which are not small emitters in accordance with Article
55(1) or which do not intend to use a small emitter tool in accordance with Article 55(2):’;
(iii) the following point (3), is inserted:
‘3. For the purpose of monitoring non-CO
2
aviation effects, the monitoring plan shall contain,
as relevant, the following information for aircraft operators not using only NEATS to
determine the non-CO
2
aviation effects:
(a)
(a) description of the fuel burn and emission estimation module, the
CO
2
(e) calculation model and associated IT tools that the aircraft
operators intends to use;
(b) a description and a flowchart of the monitoring process of data
relative to the CO
2
(e) calculation model as described in Annex IIIa,
Section 4 to this Regulation;
(c) a description of the written procedure for ensuring that appropriate
data is used to input into the CO
2
(e) calculation models in accordance
with Annex IIIa to this Regulation and that climate effects of all non-CO
2
agents on a per flight basis are taken into account;
(d) a description of the written procedure for identifying and assessing
data gaps and applying the default values described in Annex IIIa,
Section 5 and Annex IIIb to this Regulation, to complete the data gaps.’;
(b)
(c)
(d)
(c)
in Section 4, point (3), is replaced by the following:
‘3. where applicable, a description of the procedure used to assess if zero-rated fuel
streams comply with Article 38(5), or 39a(3), or 39a(4) and, where relevant, Article
75m(2) of this Regulation;’;
(48)
(a)
Annex II is amended as follows:
Section 1 is amended as follows:
(i) paragraph 2 is replaced by the following:
‘Where Table 1 does not include activities listed in Annex I to Directive 2003/87/EC
and the mass balance set out in Article 25 of this Regulation is not applied, the operator
shall use the tiers listed in Table 1 under ‘Combustion of fuels and fuels used as process
input’ for those activities.’;
(ii) Table 1 is amended as follows:
- the eleventh row, heading ‘Refining
of mineral oil’,
is replaced by the following:
‘Refining of oil’;
- the fifty-first row, heading ‘Primary
aluminium production’,
is replaced by the
following:
EN
37
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0039.png
‘Primary aluminium or alumina production’;
- the following row is added at the end of the Table:
CO
2
capture, transfer and geological storage in storage site permitted under Directive
2009/31/EC
Mass balance of CO
2
CO
2
transferred into or out
± 7,5 % ± 5 %
transferred
from an installation, transport
infrastructure or storage site,
vented, leaked or fugitive
emissions [t]
CO
2
venting, leakage, CO
2
vented, leaked or from ±17,5 % ± 12,5
and fugitive
fugitive emissions [t]
%
emissions
’;
(b)
in Section 2.1, the first paragraph is replaced by the following:
‘Where a biomass fraction, or RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction
is determined for a mixed fuel or material, the tiers defined shall relate to the
preliminary emission factor. For fossil fuels and materials, the tiers shall relate to the
emission factor.’;
(c)
Section 2.4, is replaced by the following:
Tier 1:
The operator shall apply an applicable value published by the competent
authority or the Commission, or values in accordance with Article 31(1).
Tier 2:
The operator shall apply an estimation method approved in accordance with
the second subparagraph of Article 39(2).
Tier 3a:
The operator shall apply analyses in accordance with the first sub-paragraph
of Article 39(2), and in accordance with Articles 32 to 35.
Tier 3b:
For fuels originating from a production process with defined and traceable
input streams, the operator may base the estimation on a material balance of fossil
and biomass carbon entering and leaving the process, such as the mass balance
system in accordance with Article 30(1) of Directive (EU) 2018/2001.
Where an operator assumes a fossil fraction of 100% in accordance with Article 39(1) of this
Regulation, no tier shall be assigned for the biomass fraction.’;
(d)
the following Section 2.5 is inserted:
Tier 1:
The operator shall determine the RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-
carbon fraction based on the mass balance system in accordance with Article 30(1) of
Directive (EU) 2018/2001.
‘2.5 Tiers for RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction
‘2.4
Tiers for biomass fraction
± 2,5 %
± 1,5 %
± 7,5 %
EN
38
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0040.png
Where an operator assumes a fossil fraction of 100% in accordance with Article
39a(1) of this Regulation, no tier shall be assigned for the RFNBO or RCF fraction
or synthetic low-carbon fraction.’;
(e)
(i)
Section 3.1 is amended as follows:
the third subparagraph is replaced by the following:
‘Where a biomass fraction or RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction
is determined for a mixed fuel or material, the tiers defined shall relate to the total
carbon content. The biomass fraction of the carbon shall be determined using the tiers
defined in Section 2.4 of this Annex. The RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-
carbon fraction of the carbon shall be determined using the tiers defined in Section 2.5
of this Annex.’;
(ii)
in the subheading Tier 2b, the first sentence is replaced by the following:
‘Tier 2b: The operator shall derive the carbon content from emission factors for the
fuel based on one of the following established proxies in combination with an
empirical correlation as determined at least once per year in accordance with Articles
32 to 35 of this Regulation:’;
(f)
the following Section 3.4 is added:
‘3.4
Tiers for RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction
The tiers defined in Section 2.5 of this Annex shall be used.’;
(g)
(g) in Section 4, before Section 4.1, the following paragraph is inserted:
‘By way of derogation from the provisions in this section and the following sub-
sections, operators may rate process emissions from materials as zero, provided those
materials meet all the following conditions:
(i)
(ii)
do not meet the definitions of RFNBOs or RCFs or synthetic low-carbon fuels;
were produced in another installation covered by Directive 2003/87/EC;
(iii) CO2 was chemically bound to produce the materials;
(iv) the installation that emitted the CO2 in point (iii), included this CO2 in its
annual emissions report;
(v)
do not meet the specification of a product that is listed in the delegated
Regulation adopted pursuant to Article 12(3b) of Directive 2003/87/EC.’;
(h) the following Section 4.7 is added:
‘4.7 Tiers for the RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction
The tiers defined in Section 2.5 of this Annex shall be used.’;
(49)
(a)
Annex IIa is amended as follows:
in Section 2.1, a second subparagraph is inserted after the first subparagraph:
‘Where a RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction is determined for
a mixed fuel, the tiers defined shall relate to the preliminary emission factor’;
(b)
the following Section 2.3a is inserted:
‘2.3a Tiers for RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-carbon fraction
EN
39
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0041.png
Tier 1: The operator shall determine RFNBO or RCF fraction or synthetic low-
carbon fraction based on the mass balance system in accordance with Article 30(1) of
Directive (EU) 2018/2001.
Where an operator assumes a fossil fraction of 100% in accordance with Article
39a(1) of this Regulation, no tier shall be assigned for the RFNBO or RCF fraction
or synthetic low-carbon fraction.’;
(50)
in Annex III, the title is replaced by the following:
‘Monitoring methodologies for emissions from aviation
(Article 53)’;
(51)
the following Annexes IIIa and IIIb are inserted:
‘ANNEX IIIa
Monitoring methodologies for non-CO
2
aviation effects (Article 56a)
1.
1.
DEFINITIONS RELATED TO NON-CO
2
AVIATION EFFECTS
‘flight information’ means at the minimum the call sign as provided in Article 51 of
this Regulation, the day and time of departure and arrival of the flight, expressed in
Coordinated Universal Time (UTC) and the ICAO codes and/or the International Air
Transport Association's (IATA) location identifiers for origin and destination airports
allowing for unique identification of the given flight;
flight phase information’ means the split of data (e.g. aircraft 4D position, fuel flow)
according to operational flight phases (take-off, climb, cruise, etc.);
‘operation flight envelope’ means the boundaries of altitude, aircraft speed, and load
factor for each flight phase;
‘true airspeed’ means the speed of the aircraft relative to the air mass through which
it is flying, in meters per second (m/s);
‘aircraft 4D position’ means the four-dimensional position of an aircraft defined by
its latitude, in decimal degree; longitude, in decimal degree; and altitude, in pressure
altitude, at any given moment of time between beginning and end of the flight;
‘time stamp’ means a snapshot of data (e.g. aircraft 4D position, fuel flow) that
corresponds to any given moment of time, in seconds, during flight and that is to be
considered together with time interval;
time interval’ means the time, in seconds, between two-time stamps during the flight,
not exceeding 60 seconds;
‘latest flight plan’ means the latest flight plan available and acknowledged by
relevant air navigation service for a given flight, before it takes place. The latest
flight plan can be the Eurocontrol’s Regulated Tactical Flight Model (RTFM), or
alternatively, the Eurocontrol’s Filed Tactical Flight Model (FTFM) or equivalent in
terms of data accuracy;
‘flown flight trajectory’ means the trajectory followed by the aircraft from its point
of origin (departure) to its destination (arrival), constituted by all the time stamps,
recorded during the flight. The flown flight trajectory can be sourced from the flight
data recorder equipment or third-party. Its accuracy should be equivalent, where
possible, to Eurocontrol’s Current Tactical Flight Model (CTFM);
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
EN
40
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0042.png
10.
‘flight data recorder equipment’ a specialized electronic device installed on the
aircraft for the purpose of recording various parameters and events during flight
operations. These parameters may include but are not limited to flight control inputs,
aircraft performance information, engine data, navigation information.
‘three-dimensional radiative variables’ means number of variables such as radiative
flux density, radiative heating rates, that describe how radiation varies across space,
including the Earth’s surface and atmosphere, and how it changes over time;
‘pressure’ means the force, in Pascals (Pa), exerted by the weight of the air in the
atmosphere above a given point where the aircraft is situated at any given moment of
time during flight taking into account three-dimensional radiative variables;
.‘air ambient temperature’ means the temperature of the air, in Kelvin (K),
surrounding an aircraft at any given moment of time during the flight and given for
three-dimensional radiative variables;
.‘specific humidity’ means the ratio of water vapor per kilogram of total air mass
(kg/kg) surrounding an aircraft at any given moment of time during flight and given
for three-dimensional radiative variables;
.‘International Standard Atmosphere (ISA)’ means a standard against which to
compare the actual atmosphere at any point and time, based on the specific values of
pressure, density, and temperature at mean sea level, each of which decreases with
increase in height;
.‘basic weather data’ means the category of information encompassing for each
flight, at least the pressure, the air ambient temperature and the specific humidity,
used in the fuel burn and emission estimation modules. Here, these values can be
estimated, at the minimum, through standardised, altitude-dependent correction
and/or be based on third party post-operational observations;
.‘relative humidity over ice’ means the concentration of water vapour, in percentage,
present in the air compared to its concentration at the saturation point of ice;
.‘eastward and northward wind’ means the horizontal speed of air moving towards
the East or North, in meters per second, at any given moment of time during flight
and given for three-dimensional radiative variables;
‘vertical velocity’ means the speed of air motion in the upward or downward
direction (in Pa/s), where negative values of vertical velocity indicate upward
motion. It is necessary to calculate, e.g., advection and wind shear;
.‘specific cloud ice water content’ means the mass of cloud ice particles per kilogram
of the total mass of moist air (kg/kg) surrounding an aircraft at any given moment of
time during flight and given for three-dimensional radiative variables;
.‘geopotential’ means the gravitational field strength experienced by an aircraft at
different altitudes, at any given moment of time during flight, in square meters per
squared second (m
2
/s
2
) and given for three-dimensional radiative variables;
.‘outgoing longwave radiation’ means the total radiation emitted to the space by earth
atmosphere system, in W/m
2
, at any given moment of time during flight and given
for three-dimensional radiative variables;
.‘reflected solar radiation’ means the portion of sunlight that is reflected back into
space by the Earth’s surface, clouds, aerosols, and other atmospheric particles, in
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
EN
41
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0043.png
W/m
2
, at any given moment of time during flight and given for three-dimensional
radiative variables;
24.
‘solar direct radiation’ means the portion of sunlight that reaches the Earth’s surface
directly from the Sun without being scattered or reflected by the atmosphere or
clouds, in W/m
2
, at any given moment of time during flight and given for three-
dimensional radiative variables;
‘common reference Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP) model’ refers to a
computational system utilised in meteorology, comprising algorithms and
mathematical formulations implemented in software, designed to simulate, and
forecast atmospheric conditions over a defined spatial and temporal domain (spatial
grid). In the case of the enhanced weather data, a common reference NWP model is
provided by the Commission through NEATS;
‘enhanced weather data’ means the category of information encompassing for each
flight, the pressure, the air ambient temperature, the specific humidity, the relative
humidity over ice, the eastward and northward wind, the vertical velocity, the
specific cloud ice water content, the geopotential, the outgoing longwave, reflected
solar and solar direct radiation, taken as input from a common reference NWP
model, provided by the Commission through NEATS;
‘engine identifier’ means the aircraft engine unique identifier number as contained in
the ICAO engine emissions databank, or equivalent, allowing to unequivocally
identify the engines attached to the aircraft, through internationally recognized
standardised lists;
‘aircraft mass’ means the mass in kilogrammes of the aircraft along the trajectory,
which equals to subtracting from the take-off mass the fuel burn during flight at any
given moment of time. If the aircraft mass is not available, it can be approximated
based on either the take-off mass or the load factor, and either the given fuel flow or
the fuel flow as calculated by an aircraft performance simulation using the fuel burn
module;
‘take-off mass’ means the aircraft mass at beginning of the take-off run, including
everything and everyone carried at that moment, in kilograms. It is used to
approximate the aircraft mass if the latter is not provided. If the take-off mass is not
available, it can be approximated based on the load factor;
‘maximum take-off mass’ is the maximum mass, in kilograms, at which the pilot of
an aircraft is allowed to take off, as specified by the aircraft manufacturer;
‘maximum payload mass’ is the maximum mass of passengers and related baggage,
mass of cargo, including mail and hand luggage, that can be transported by an
aircraft. Values for maximum payload can be retrieved by the applied fuel burn
module;
‘load factor’ means the weight of passengers, cargo and baggage, including mail and
hand luggage, expressed as fraction of the maximum payload mass. The load factor
is used to approximate the take-off mass if the latter is not provided. If the load factor
is not available, a conservative default value shall be used, in accordance with Annex
IIIa, Section 5;
‘fuel flow’ means the mass of fuel in kilograms that passes through the aircraft fuel
system and into the aircraft’s engines per second during the flight. It can be modeled
during flight planning, measured in-flight, or estimated through fuel burn module;
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
EN
42
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0044.png
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
‘aircraft engine efficiency’ means the percentage of useful thrust generated by an
aircraft engine relative to the energy input from fuel;
‘aircraft performance’ means the category of information encompassing fuel flow
and aircraft engine efficiency by all-time stamps;
‘hydrogen per carbon (H/C) ratio of fuel per flight’ means the number of hydrogen
atoms (H) per carbon atom (C) per molecule of the fuel used per flight;
‘aromatic content of the fuel per flight’ means the percentage of aromatic
hydrocarbons present in the fuel used per flight;
‘flight fuel properties’ means the category of information encompassing for each
flight the hydrogen per carbon ratio, aromatic content, and the net calorific value of
the fuel on board;
NON-CO
2
AVIATION EFFECTS TRACKING SYSTEM (NEATS)
2.
NEATS is provided by the Commission to aircraft operators, to accredited verifiers and to
competent authorities for the purpose of facilitating and, to the extent possible, automating
monitoring, reporting and verification of non-CO
2
aviation effects, in order to minimise any
administrative burden.
NEATS is aligned with the principles established in Article 75(1) of this Regulation and
provides a dedicated and secured user interface per aircraft operator, verifier and competent
authority.
Monitoring:
NEATS streamlines the monitoring process as it incorporates directly, or gives access to,
available third-party collected flight trajectories and weather data allowing to minimise
monitoring by aircraft operators to aircraft properties, as well as to fuel properties, where
needed, as defined in Annex IIIa, Section 1 or to render it fully automatic depending on use of
default values.
NEATS incorporates the CO
2
(e) calculation approaches as listed in paragraph 4 of Article 56a
of this Regulation and provides a common reference NWP model, where enhanced weather
data is needed (Method C). This results into the calculation of CO
2
(e) per flight as part of the
monitored data.
Reporting:
NEATS streamlines the reporting exercise referred to in Article 68(5) of this Regulation. The
tool generates automatically the XML table referred to in Annex X, Section 2a(9) to this
Regulation at the end of each reporting year, minimising administrative burden associated
with reporting.
Verification:
NEATS streamlines the verification and cross-checks done respectively by the verifier and the
competent authority. It provides the means to verify a CO
2
(e) per flight, while protecting
confidential data.
Data storage:
EN
43
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0045.png
NEATS allows to store all the data (from aircraft operators and from third parties), securely
encoding and protecting from release confidential data, where such data is uploaded by the
aircraft operator on NEATS, as long as it is identified as confidential by the aircraft operator.
Transparency:
NEATS relies on state-of-art models to calculate the CO
2
(e) for non-CO
2
effects. Aircraft
operators may develop their own or use third-party tools, provided they comply with the
requirements laid down in this Annex.
NEATS shall feed into a public website summarising the non-confidential data and CO
2
(e)
per flight and per aircraft operator.
3.
FUEL BURN AND EMISSION ESTIMATION MODULES FOR NON-CO
2
AVIATION EFFECTS
Fuel burn module:
The fuel burn module is based on a kinetic approach to aircraft performance modelling, which
enables to accurately predict aircraft trajectories and the associated fuel consumption over the
entire operation flight envelope and in all phases of a flight. The model processes the
theoretical fundamentals to compute aircraft performance parameters, including information
on drag, lift, weight, thrust, fuel consumption, as well as the speeds for the climb, cruise, and
descent phases of an aircraft, assuming normal aircraft operations. In addition, aircraft-
specific coefficients are key data inputs for the computation of the flight trajectory planning
of specific aircraft types.
Emission-estimation module:
The emission-estimation module enables to compute aircraft engine emissions of NOx, HC,
and CO by means of correlation equations without proprietary airplane and engine
performance models along with proprietary engine emissions characterisations. This module
applies exhaust emission indices (EIs) from the ICAO engine type certification under
predefined reference conditions on the ground and estimates the corresponding EIs during
flight conditions assuming international standard atmosphere (ISA) conditions using
correction factors for differences in the ISA conditions of temperature, pressure and
humidity.
4.
CO
2
(e) CALCULATION MODELS FOR NON-CO
2
AVIATION EFFECTS
General criteria:
In the CO
2
(e) calculation models, the aircraft operator shall consider the climate effects of all
non-CO
2
agents on a per flight basis including flight trajectories (flight plan and flown flight
trajectories), as well as aircraft and flight fuel properties. The emissions from each flight shall
be accounted for as pulse emissions. When applying the CO
2
(e) calculation models, flight
trajectory-dependent aircraft emission data shall be used to calculate all the following
elements:
(a)
(b)
composition changes;
temporal evolution of radiative forcing caused by composition changes;
EN
44
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0046.png
(c)
near surface temperature changes caused by flight trajectory-dependent
aircraft emissions.
Administrative and computational efforts shall be kept low to ensure feasibility for all
stakeholders. The model(s) shall be transparent and suitable for operational use.
Depending on the model, there are two types of requirement lists:
Method C:
For the weather-based approach, detailed climate effects of all aircraft non-CO
2
emissions at a
specific location and time shall be considered taking into account current weather information
to calculate climate-optimised four-dimensional trajectories for individual flight planning. To
allow detailed accounting of the climate effects with regards to current atmospheric
conditions, different aircraft, propulsion types, as well as fuel properties shall explicitly be
considered in the models. Estimates for the formation, life cycle and contrail climate effects
for single flights as well as the residence times for the emitted H
2
O and NO
x
and their impact
on the atmospheric composition shall be included. For being able to output advanced
information for use in daily flight planning, the model(s) shall be computationally efficient.
Each aircraft operators shall monitor the following data per flight:
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
Method D:
For the location-based simplified approach, the aircraft operator shall use climate response
model(s) to estimate the impact of all non-CO2 effects per flight on a climatological basis.
The tool(s) shall be used to assess the climate benefit of general routing options, while
accounting for general differences in aircraft, propulsion types and fuel properties through
their physical parameterisations. The CO2(e) calculated with the location-based simplified
approach shall average out any large deviations for individual flights over a longer period of
time. The model(s) should ensure reduced efforts in data need, computation, and handling, as
compared to the model(s) for the weather-based approach.
By way of derogation of Method C, small emitters, as defined in Article 55(1) of this
Regulation, may monitor the following data per flight:
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(f)
flight information;
flight trajectory, defined by the flown flight trajectory;
basic weather data;
aircraft properties;
(optional) aircraft performance along the flight information;
(optional) flight fuel properties.
flight information;
flight trajectory, defined at the minimum, as the latest flight plan;
enhanced weather data;
aircraft properties;
(optional) aircraft performance information. Planned fuel flow is to be used
preferentially, in order to align with the latest flight plan data available;
flight fuel properties.
EN
45
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0047.png
5.
USE OF DEFAULT VALUES FOR NON-CO
2
AVIATION EFFECTS
Subject to further scrutiny by the competent authority and the Commission, the use of default
values shall always result in higher CO
2
(e) per flight compared to what can be obtained with
monitored data.
1.
Flight trajectory:
(a)
For the purpose of applying Method C, the latest flight plan shall be provided.
If the RTFM, or equivalent, is not available, the FTFM, or equivalent shall be
used as default. In such case, where data by time stamp is not available, it can
be calculated by linear interpolation of measured data stemming from the two
measurement times closest before and after the time stamp under consideration,
within the same flight phase, provided it results in homogenous flight trajectory
for the given flight phase, especially the cruise phase.
For the purpose of applying Method D:
(i)
(ii)
the flown flight trajectory shall always be provided. If the CTFM, or
equivalent, is not available, the RTFM or FTFM can be used.
where data by time stamp is not available, it can be calculated by linear
interpolation of measured data stemming from the two measurement
times closest before and after the time stamp under consideration, within
the same flight phase, provided it results in homogenous flight trajectory
for the given flight phase, especially the cruise phase.
(b)
2.
Aircraft properties:
(a)
Engine identifier: where no engine identifier or equivalent, is provided,
conservative default values per aircraft type, as defined in Annex IIIb to this
Regulation, shall be used.
(b)
Aircraft mass: if the aircraft mass is not provided, the aircraft operator can
simulate the aircraft mass by using the take-off mass. If neither the aircraft mass, nor
the take-off mass are available, the load factor can be used to approximate the take-off
mass. If no load factor is provided, a default value of 1 is used.
3.
Aircraft performance:
Fuel flow: if the fuel flow is not provided from the flight data recorder equipment, the aircraft
operator can use other means to derive the fuel flow, in line with Annex IIIa, Section 1 to this
Regulation defining fuel flow, taking into account the thrust which depends on the aircraft’s
mass and true airspeed.
4.
Flight fuel properties:
If no flight fuel properties are provided, the upper limits of Jet A-1 fuel according to the
ASTM Standard Specification for Aviation Turbine Fuels, are assumed:
(a)
(b)
(c)
Aromatic content: 25% volume;
Sulphur: 0.3% mass;
Naphthalene: 3.0% volume.
EN
46
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0048.png
ANNEX IIIb
Conservative default engine values per aircraft type
ICAO 
A148 
A19N 
A20N 
A21N 
A306 
A30B 
A310 
A318 
A319 
A320 
A321 
A332 
A333 
A337 
A338 
A339 
A343 
A346 
A358 
A359 
A35K 
A388 
A3ST 
AN72 
B38M 
B39M 
B463 
B701 
B703 
First UID 
13ZM003 
01P22PW163 
01P22PW163 
01P20CM132 
1PW048 
1GE007 
1PW027 
7CM049 
1IA001 
1IA001 
3IA008 
4PW067 
4PW067 
3RR029 
04P24RR146 
02P23RR141 
2CM015 
8RR045 
01P18RR125 
01P21RR125 
01P21RR125 
9EA001 
1GE021 
1ZM001 
01P20CM138 
01P20CM138 
1TL003 
1PW001 
1PW001 
EN
47
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0049.png
B721 
B731 
B732 
B733 
B734 
B735 
B736 
B737 
B738 
B739 
B741 
B742 
B743 
B744 
B748 
B74S 
B752 
B753 
B762 
B763 
B764 
B772 
B773 
B77L 
B77W 
B778 
B779 
B788 
B789 
B78X 
BCS1 
BCS3 
C550 
C560 
1PW008 
01P20CM138 
1PW008 
1CM007 
1CM007 
1CM007 
3CM031 
2CM015 
2CM015 
3CM034 
8PW088 
1RR011 
1PW029 
1RR010 
13GE157 
8PW088 
1RR011 
3RR034 
1PW026 
5GE085 
5GE085 
3GE060 
2RR024 
01P21GE217 
01P21GE217 
01P21GE217 
01P21GE217 
02P23RR138 
02P23RR138 
02P23RR138 
16PW111 
16PW111 
1PW037 
1PW037 
EN
48
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0050.png
C650 
C680 
C68A 
C700 
C750 
CL30 
CL35 
CL60 
CRJ2 
CRJ7 
CRJ9 
CRJX 
E135 
E145 
E170 
E190 
E195 
E290 
E295 
E35L 
E545 
E550 
E55P 
E75L 
E75S 
F100 
F2TH 
F900 
FA10 
FA50 
FA7X 
FA8X 
G280 
GA5C 
1AS002 
7PW077 
7PW077 
01P18HN013 
6AL024 
11HN003 
01P14HN011 
10GE130 
01P05GE189 
01P11GE202 
01P08GE190 
01P08GE193 
01P10AL033 
6AL006 
01P08GE197 
10GE130 
10GE130 
04P20PW200 
04P20PW201 
6AL006 
11HN003 
01P14HN016 
01P14HN016 
01P08GE197 
01P08GE197 
1RR020 
01P07PW146 
1AS001 
1AS002 
1AS002 
03P16PW192 
03P15PW193 
01P11HN012 
01P22PW142 
EN
49
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0051.png
GA6C 
GALX 
GL5T 
GL7T 
GLEX 
GLF4 
GLF5 
GLF6 
H25B 
H25C 
HA4T 
IL62 
IL86 
LJ35 
LJ45 
LJ55 
MD11 
MD90 
RJ85 
SU95 
T154 
’;
(52)
(a)
(b)
(c)
01P22PW141 
7PW077 
4BR004 
21GE185 
4BR004 
11RR048 
4BR004 
4BR004 
1AS001 
7PW077 
01P07PW146 
1KK001 
1KK003 
1AS001 
1AS002 
1AS002 
5GE085 
1IA001 
1TL004 
01P11PJ004 
1KK001 
Annex IV is amended as follows:
The title of Section 2 is replaced by the following:
The title of Section 5 is replaced by the following:
in Section 6, point (A), the first paragraph is replaced by the following:
‘R
EFINING OF OIL AS LISTED IN
A
NNEX
I
TO
D
IRECTIVE
2003/87/EC’;
‘P
RODUCTION OF IRON AND STEEL AS LISTED IN
A
NNEX
I
TO
D
IRECTIVE
2003/87/EC’;
‘The operator shall not apply the provisions in this section for the monitoring and reporting
of CO
2
emissions from the production of iron and steel and primary aluminium.’;
(d)
Section 7 is amended as follows:
(i)
The title is replaced by the following:
‘CO
2
EMISSIONS FROM PRODUCTION OR PROCESSING OF PRIMARY ALUMINIUM OR ALUMINA
AS LISTED IN
A
NNEX
I
TO
D
IRECTIVE
2003/87/EC’;
EN
50
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0052.png
(ii)
in Point (A), the first and second paragraphs are replaced by the following:
‘The operator shall apply the provisions of this section to the monitoring and reporting of CO
2
emissions from the production of alumina (Al
2
O
3
), the production of electrodes for primary
aluminium smelting, including stand-alone plants for the production of such electrodes, and
the consumption of electrodes during electrolysis.
The operator shall consider at least the following potential sources for CO
2
emissions: fuels
for the production of heat or steam, Al
2
O
3
production, electrode production, reduction of
Al
2
O
3
during electrolysis which is related to electrode consumption, and use of soda ash or
other carbonates for waste gas scrubbing.’;
(e)
in Section 10, point (A), the second paragraph is replaced by the following:
‘Where the burnt lime and the CO2 stemming from the limestone are used for purification
processes, the CO2 shall be considered emitted, unless the CO2 is bound in a product that
satisfies the conditions set out in Article 49a(1) of this Regulation.’;
(f)
in Section 17, point (B), the second paragraph is replaced by the following:
‘Where CO
2
from ammonia production is used as feedstock for the production of urea or other
chemicals, or transferred out of the installation for any use not covered by Article 49(1) of this
Regulation, the related amount of CO
2
shall be considered as emitted by the installation
producing the CO
2
, unless the CO
2
is bound in a product that satisfies the conditions set out
in Article 49a(1) of this Regulation.’;
(g)
Section 20 is amended as follows:
(i) in Point (A), points (b) and (c) are replaced by the following:
‘(b) raw materials, including vent gas from calcination of limestone;
(c)waste gases from washing or filtration steps after carbonation.’;
(ii) Point (B) is replaced by the following:
‘B.
Specific monitoring rules
Emissions from combustion processes, including flue gas scrubbing shall be monitored in
accordance with Section 1 of this Annex. Process emissions from raw material components
and additives shall be monitored in accordance with Section 4 of Annex II to this Regulation.
Intermediary CO
2
for the production of soda ash shall be considered as emitted by the
installation producing the CO
2
, unless the CO
2
is bound in a product that satisfies the
conditions set out in Article 49a(1) of this Regulation.’;
(h)
Section 21 is amended as follows:
(i) in Point (A), the first paragraph is replaced by the following:
‘CO2 capture shall be performed either by a dedicated installation receiving CO2 by transfer
from one or more other installations, or by the same installation carrying out the activities
producing the captured CO2 under the same greenhouse gas emissions permit. All parts of the
installation related to CO2 capture, and transfer to a CO2 transport infrastructure or to a site
for geological storage of CO2 greenhouse gas emissions, including any functionally
connected ancillary facilities, such as CO2 intermediate storage, booster, liquefaction,
gasification, purification stations or heaters, shall be included in the greenhouse gas emissions
permit and accounted for in the associated monitoring plan. In the case of the installation
carrying out other activities covered by Directive 2003/87/EC, the emissions of those
activities shall be monitored in accordance with the other relevant sections of this Annex.’;
EN
51
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0053.png
(ii) Point (B), is replaced by the following:
‘B.
Quantification of transferred and emitted CO2 amounts
B.1. Installation level quantification
Each operator shall calculate the emissions by taking into account the potential CO
2
emissions
from all emission relevant processes at the installation, as well as the amount of CO
2
captured
and transferred to the CO
2
infrastructure, using the following formula:
E
capture installation
= T
input
+ E
without capture
– T
for storage
Where:
E
capture installation
= Total greenhouse gas emissions of the capture installation;
T
input
= Amount of CO
2
transferred to the capture installation, determined either based on one
or more source streams as in a mass balance methodology in accordance with Article 25 or
based on a measurement-based methodology in accordance with Article 40 to 46 and Article
49 of this Regulation.
E
without capture
= Emissions of the installation assuming the CO
2
were not captured, meaning the
sum of the emissions from all other activities at the installation, monitored in accordance with
relevant sections of Annex IV, including Method B in Section 22 of Annex IV to this
Regulation for any functionally connected ancillary facilities;
T
for storage
= Amount of CO
2
transferred to a CO
2
transport infrastructure or a storage site,
determined either based on one or more source streams as in a mass balance methodology in
accordance with Article 25 or based on a measurement-based methodology in accordance
with Article 40 to 46 and Article 49 of this Regulation.
In cases where CO
2
capture is carried out by the same installation as the one from which the
captured CO
2
originates, the operator shall use zero for T
input
.
In cases of stand-alone capture installations, the operators of these installations shall take into
consideration the following:
(a) the operator shall consider E
without capture
to represent the amount of emissions that occur
from other sources than the CO
2
transferred to the installation for capture. The operator shall
determine those emissions in accordance with this Regulation;
(b) by way of derogation from the monitoring methodology described in this section, the
operator may monitor the emissions of the installation by using Method B as described in
Section 22 of Annex IV to this Regulation.
In the case of stand-alone capture installations, the operator of the installation transferring
CO
2
to the capture installation shall deduct the amount T
input
from the emissions of its
installation based either as one or more source streams as in a mass balance methodology in
accordance with Article 25 or based on a measurement-based methodology in accordance
with Article 49 of this Regulation.
EN
52
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0054.png
B.2. Determination of transferred CO
2
Each operator shall determine the amount of CO
2
transferred from and to the capture
installation based either as one or more source streams as in a mass balance methodology in
accordance with Article 25 or based on a measurement-based methodology in accordance
Articles 40 to 46 and Article 49 of this Regulation.’;
(i) Section 22 is replaced by the following:
‘ 22. Determination of greenhouse gas emissions from the transport of CO2 for
geological storage in a storage site permitted under Directive 2009/31/EC
A.
Scope
The boundaries for monitoring and reporting emissions from CO
2
transport shall be laid down
in the CO
2
transport infrastructure’s greenhouse gas emissions permit, including all ancillary
facilities functionally connected to the transport infrastructure, such as CO
2
intermediate
storage, booster, liquefaction, gasification, purification stations or heaters. Each transport
infrastructure shall have a minimum of one start point and one end point, each connected to
other installations or CO
2
transport infrastructure carrying out one or more of the activities:
capture, transport or geological storage of CO
2
. Start and end points may be set at bifurcations
of the transport infrastructure and at cross national borders. Start and end points as well as the
installations or CO
2
transport infrastructure they are connecting to, shall be laid down in the
greenhouse gas emissions permit.
Each operator of a CO
2
transport infrastructure shall consider at least the following potential
emission sources for CO
2
emissions: combustion and other processes at installations
functionally connected to the transport infrastructure including booster stations and
liquefaction stations; combustion units, including internal combustion units in CO
2
transport
vehicles, to the extent emissions are not subject to surrender obligations related to activities
listed in Annexes I or III to Directive 2003/87/EC in that same reporting year; fugitive
emissions from the transport infrastructure; vented emissions from the transport
infrastructure; and emissions from leakage incidents in the transport infrastructure.
CO
2
transported for purposes other than for geological storage in a storage site permitted
under Directive 2009/31/EC shall not be part of the boundaries for monitoring and reporting
emissions by the CO
2
transport infrastructure. In cases where the same infrastructure is used
for the transport of CO
2
for multiple purposes, including for geological storage in a storage
site permitted under Directive 2009/31/EC, in a manner where the different consignments
cannot be distinguished, the operator of a CO
2
transport infrastructure shall indicate this in the
greenhouse gas emissions permit and establish a method for recording and documenting the
volumes of CO
2
transported for purposes other for geological storage in a storage site
permitted under Directive 2009/31/EC. The operator of a CO
2
transport infrastructure shall
monitor emissions resulting from the total volume of CO
2
transported but shall report as
emitted the share of the emissions corresponding to the volume of CO
2
transported for
geological storage in a storage site permitted under Directive 2009/31/EC divided by total
volume of CO
2
transported.
B.
Quantification Methodologies for CO
2
The CO
2
transport infrastructure operator shall determine emissions using one of the
following methods:
EN
53
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0055.png
(a) Method A (overall mass balance of all input and output streams) set out in subsection
B.1;
(b)Method B (monitoring of emission sources individually) set out in subsection B.2.
The operator shall apply Method B unless the operator can demonstrate to the competent
authority that the application of Method A will lead to more reliable results with lower
uncertainty of the overall emissions, using best available technology and knowledge at the
time of the application for the greenhouse gas emissions permit and approval of the
monitoring plan, without incurring unreasonable costs. Where Method B is applied, each
operator shall demonstrate to the satisfaction of the competent authority that the overall
uncertainty for the annual level of greenhouse gas emissions for the operator’s transport
infrastructure does not exceed 7,5 %.
The operator of a CO
2
transport infrastructure using Method B shall not add CO
2
received
from another installation or CO
2
transport infrastructure permitted in accordance with
Directive 2003/87/EC to its calculated level of emissions, and shall not subtract from its
calculated level of emissions any CO
2
transferred to another installation or CO
2
transport
infrastructure permitted in accordance with Directive 2003/87/EC.
Each operator of a CO
2
transport infrastructure shall use Method A for the validation of the
results of Method B at least once annually. For that validation, the operator may use lower
tiers for the application of Method A.
B.1.
Method A
Each operator shall determine emissions in accordance with the following formula:
Emissions [t CO2]=E
transport infrastructure
+∑iT
IN,i
 − ∑iT
OUT,i
− ΔE
in transit
Where:
Emissions = Total CO
2
emissions of the transport infrastructure [t CO
2
];
E
transport infrastructure
= Amount of CO
2
[t CO
2
] from the transport infrastructure’s own activity,
meaning not emissions stemming from the CO
2
transported, but being emitted from
combustion or other processes functionally connected to the transport infrastructure,
monitored in accordance with the relevant sections of Annex IV to this Regulation;
T
IN,i
= Amount of CO
2
transferred to the transport infrastructure at entry point
i,
determined
either based on one or more source streams as in a mass balance methodology in accordance
with Article 25 or based on a measurement-based methodology in accordance with Articles 40
to 46 and Article 49 of this Regulation.
T
OUT,i
= Amount of CO
2
transferred out of the transport infrastructure at exit point i,
determined either based on one or more source streams as in a mass balance methodology in
accordance with Article 25 or based on a measurement-based methodology in accordance
with Articles 40 to 46 and Article 49 of this Regulation.
ΔE
in transit
= Amount of CO
2
transferred to the transport infrastructure at entry point
i,
that is
not transferred to another installation or CO2 transport infrastructure in the same reporting
period but by the deadline indicated in Article 49(7) of this Regulation in the year after the
reporting period. Corresponding amounts shall not be taken into account for T
OUT,i
for the
subsequent reporting period.
EN
54
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0056.png
B.2.
Method B
Each operator shall determine emissions considering all processes relevant to emissions at the
installation as well as the amount of CO
2
captured and transferred to the transport
infrastructure using the following formula:
Emissions [t CO
2
]= E
 fugitive
+ E
vented
+ E
 leakage events
+ E
transport infrastructue
Where:
Emissions = Total CO
2
emissions of the transport infrastructure [t CO
2
];
E
fugitive
= Amount of fugitive emissions [t CO
2
] from CO
2
transported in the transport
infrastructure, including from seals, valves, intermediate compressor stations and intermediate
storage facilities;
E
vented
= Amount of vented emissions [t CO
2
] from CO
2
transported in the transport
infrastructure;
E
leakage events
= Amount of CO
2
[t CO
2
] transported in the transport infrastructure, which is
emitted as the result of the failure of one or more components of the transport infrastructure;
E
transport infrastructure
= Amount of CO
2
[t CO
2
] from the transport infrastructure’s own activity,
meaning not emissions stemming from the CO
2
transported, but being emitted from
combustion or other processes functionally connected to the transport infrastructure,
monitored in accordance with the relevant sections of Annex IV to this Regulation.
B.2.1.
Fugitive emissions from the transport infrastructure
The operator of a CO
2
transport infrastructure shall consider fugitive emissions from at
least any of the following types of equipment:
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
seals;
measurement devices;
valves;
intermediate compressor stations;
intermediate storage facilities including those mounted onto CO
2
transport
vehicles.
The operator shall determine average emission rates
ER
(expressed in g CO
2
/unit time) per
piece of equipment per occurrence where fugitive emissions can be anticipated at the
beginning of operation, and by the end of the first reporting year in which the transport
infrastructure is in operation at the latest. The operator shall review those factors at least every
5 years in the light of the best available techniques and knowledge.
The operator shall calculate fugitive emissions by multiplying the number of pieces of
equipment in each category by the emission factor and adding up the results for the single
categories as shown in the following equation:
���������������������������������������������������������������� ����������������
[
������������������������
2
] =
�½ �½
����������������
[������������������������
2
⁄������������������������������������������������
]
∙ ��������
����������������������������������������
�½
/10
6
����������������������������������������������������������������
EN
55
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0057.png
The number of occurrences (N
occurr
) shall be the number of pieces of the given equipment per
category, multiplied by the number of time units per year.
B.2.2.
Emissions from leakage events
The operator of a CO2 transport infrastructure shall provide evidence of the system integrity
by using representative (spatial and time-related) temperature and pressure data. Where the
data indicates that a leakage has occurred, the operator shall calculate the amount of CO2
leaked with a suitable methodology documented in the monitoring plan, based on industry
best practice guidelines, including by use of the differences in temperature and pressure data
compared to integrity related average pressure and temperature values.
B.2.3. Vented emissions
Each operator of a CO2 transport infrastructure shall provide in the monitoring plan an
analysis regarding potential situations of venting emissions, including for maintenance or
emergency reasons, and provide a suitable documented methodology for calculating the
amount of CO2 vented, based on industry best practice guidelines.’;
(j) Section 23 is amended as follows:
(i) in Point (A), the first paragraph is replaced by the following:
The competent authority shall base the boundaries for monitoring and reporting of emissions
from geological storage of CO2 on the delimitation of the storage site and storage complex as
specified in the permit pursuant to Directive 2009/31/EC, as well as all ancillary facilities
functionally connected to the storage complex, such as CO2 intermediate storage, booster,
liquefaction, gasification, purification stations or heaters. Where leakages from the storage
complex are identified and lead to emissions or release of CO2 into the water column, the
operator shall immediately carry out all the following:
(a)
(b)
(c)
notify the competent authority;
include the leakage as a source stream or an emission source for the respective
installation;
monitor and report the emissions.’
(ii) in Point (B), the first paragraph is replaced by the following:
‘The operator of the geological storage activity shall not add CO
2
received from another
installation to its calculated level of emissions, and shall not subtract from its calculated level
of emissions any CO
2
which is geologically stored in the storage site or which is transferred to
another installation. The operator shall monitor emissions from any ancillary facilities
functionally connected to the storage complex in accordance with the provisions set out in
Section 22 of Annex IV to this Regulation.’;
(iii) Point (B1), the second paragraph is replaced by the following:
‘Each
operator shall determine V CO
2
either as one or more source streams as in a mass
balance methodology in accordance with Article 25 or by using a measurement-based
methodology in accordance with Articles 41 to 46 of this Regulation. By way of derogation
from the first sentence and upon approval by the competent authority, the operator may
include in the monitoring plan an appropriate methodology for determining V CO
2
based on
industry best practice, where the application of monitoring methodologies referred to in the
first sentence would incur unreasonable costs or the operator can demonstrate that the
EN
56
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0058.png
methodology based on industry best practice allows the amounts to be determined with at
least the same accuracy as measurement-based methodologies.’;
(iv) Point (B2), the first paragraph is replaced by the following:
‘Each operator shall consider at least the following potential additional emission sources from
enhanced hydrocarbon recovery (EHR):’;
(53)
Annex V is amended as follows:
(a) Table 1 is amended as follows:
(i) the twelfth row, heading
‘Refining of mineral oil’
is replaced by the following:
‘Refining of oil’;
(ii) the twenty-seventh row, heading
‘Primary aluminium production’
is replaced by the
following:
‘Primary
aluminium or alumina production’;
(iii) the following row is added at the end of the Table:
CO
2
capture, transfer and geological storage in storage site permitted under Directive
2009/31/EC
Mass balance of CO
2
transferred
CO
2
venting, leakage, and
fugitive emissions
’;
(54)
CO
2
transferred
Flue gas for the purpose of Article 43(4)
’;
(55)
Annex IX is amended as follows:
At least weekly
Every 50 000 tonnes of total CO
2
, but at least
once a month
in the Table of Annex VII, the following rows are inserted after the second row,
heading ‘natural gas’ :
2
2
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
2
2
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
(a) Section 2 is amended as follows:
(i) the title is replaced by the following:
‘S
PECIFIC ELEMENTS FOR STATIONARY INSTALLATIONS
:’
(ii) in point (6), the introductory sentence is replaced by the following:
‘For primary aluminium or alumina production, the following additional elements:’;
(iii) in point (7), point (b) is replaced by the following:
EN
57
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0059.png
‘representatively aggregated pressure and temperature data from a transport infrastructure’;
(iv) the following point (8) is inserted:
‘8. For CO
2
permanently chemically bound, where applicable, the following additional
elements:
(a) documentation of the amount of CO
2
permanently chemically bound;
(b) the types of products the CO
2
was chemically bound, their amounts produced and
the respective uses of the products.’;
(b) Section 3 is amended as follows:
(i) point (4) is replaced by the following:
‘For the purposes of monitoring emission, documentation on the methodology for data gaps
where applicable, the number of flights where data gaps occurred, the data used for closing
the data gaps, where they occurred, and, where the number of flights with data gaps exceeded
5% of flights that were reported, reasons for the data gaps as well as documentation of
remedial actions taken;’;
(ii) the following points (5) and (6) are inserted:
‘(5) For the purpose of monitoring and reporting of non-CO2 aviation effects, all data
monitored by the aircraft operator pursuant to Article 56b(2) of this Regulation, where such
data is used to calculate the CO2(e) per flight in accordance with the method referred to in
Article 56a of this Regulation;
(6) For the purpose of monitoring non-CO2 aviation effects and where the aircraft operator
does not use NEATS, the number of flights where data gaps occurred and appropriate default
values used of Annex IIIa, Section 5 and Annex IIIb to this Regulation for closing the data
gaps.’;
(56)
Annex X is amended as follows:
(a) Section 1 is amended as follows:
(i) the title is replaced by the following:
‘A
NNUAL EMISSION REPORTS OF STATIONARY INSTALLATIONS
’;
(ii) in point (6), point (a) is replaced by the following:
‘the total emissions expressed as t CO
2
(e), including CO
2
from biomass source streams
which do not comply with Article 38(5) of this Regulation, or from RFNBO or RCF source
streams which do not comply with Article 39a(3) of this Regulation, or from synthetic low-
carbon fuels source streams which do not comply with Article 39a(4) of this Regulation ;’;
(iii) in point (6), point (f) is replaced by the following:
‘emission factors, expressed in accordance with the requirements set out in Article 36(2) of
this Regulation; biomass fraction; zero-rated biomass fraction, RFNBO or RCF fraction,
zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction, synthetic low-carbon fraction, zero-rated synthetic
low-carbon fraction, oxidation and conversion factors, expressed as dimensionless
fractions;’;
(iv) point (7) is replaced by the following:
‘Where a mass balance methodology is applied, the mass flow, and carbon content for each
source stream into and out of the installation; biomass fraction, zero-rated biomass
fraction, RFNBO or RCF fraction, zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction, synthetic low-
EN
58
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0060.png
carbon fraction, zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fraction, and net calorific value, where
relevant;’;
(v)
(a)
amounts of biomass and of zero-rated biomass combusted or amounts of
RFNBO or RCF and of zero-rated RFNBO or RCF combusted, or amounts of
synthetic low-carbon fuels and of zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fuels
combusted, expressed in TJ, or employed in processes, expressed in t or Nm3;
CO2 emissions from biomass and from zero-rated biomass or emissions from
RFNBO or RCF and from zero-rated RFNBO or RCF, or emissions from
synthetic low-carbon fuels and of zero-rated synthetic low-carbon fuels
expressed in t CO2, where measurement-based methodology is used to
determine emissions;
a proxy for the net calorific value of the biomass or RFNBO or RCF or
synthetic low-carbon fuels source streams used as fuel, where relevant;
emissions, amounts and energy content of biomass fuels and bioliquids
combusted or RFNBO or RCF combusted, or synthetic low-carbon fuels
combusted expressed in t and TJ, and information that zero-rated biomass fuels
and bioliquids or RFNBO or RCF or synthetic low-carbon fuels comply with
Article 38(5) or Article 39a(3) or Article 39a(4) of this Regulation;
CO2 or N2O transferred to an installation or received from an installation and
any CO2 in transit, where Article 49 or 50 of this Regulation is applicable,
expressed in t CO2(e);’;
in point (8), points (a), (b), (c), (d) and (e) are replaced by the following:
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
(vi) in point (8), points (i) and (j) are inserted:
‘(i) amount of CO
2
chemically bound in product in accordance with Article 49a(1) of this
Regulation, expressed in t CO
2
;
(j) the types and amounts of products produced in which CO
2
was chemically bound in
accordance with Article 49a(1) of this Regulation, expressed in t of product;’;
(vii) in point (9), point (c) is replaced by the following:
‘(c) where applicable, a proxy for the energy content from fossil fuels and materials and
from biomass used as fuels and materials as well as from RFNBO or RCF or synthetic low-
carbon fuels.’;
(b) Section 2 is amended as follows:
(i) points (8) and (9), are replaced by the following:
‘ 8. Mass of neat fuel (in tonnes) per fuel type per State pair, including information on all
of the following:
(a)
(b)
(c)
(a) Whether the alternative aviation fuel is zero-rated in compliance with
Article 54c of this Regulation;
(b) Whether the fuel is an eligible aviation fuel;
(c) For eligible aviation fuels, the fuel type as defined in Article 3c(6) of
Directive 2003/87/EC;
59
EN
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0061.png
9. Total CO
2
emissions in tonnes of CO
2
using the preliminary emission factor as well as the
emission factor disaggregated by the Member State of departure and arrival;’;
(ii) point (12) is replaced by the following:
‘12. Memo-items:
(a) amount of alternative aviation fuels used during the reporting year (in tonnes)
listed per fuel type, and whether the fuels comply with Article 54c of this
Regulation;
(b) the net calorific value of alternative fuels;’;
(iii) point (13) is replaced by the following:
‘As an annex to the annual emission report, the aircraft operator shall include annual
emissions and annual numbers of flights per aerodrome pair. If applicable, the amount of
alternative aviation fuel and eligible aviation fuel (in tonnes) shall be indicated per
aerodrome pair. Upon request of the operator the competent authority shall treat that
information as confidential.’;
(c) Section 2a is inserted:
‘2a.
ANNUAL NON-CO
2
AVIATION EFECTS REPORTS OF AIRCRAFT
OPERATORS
For non-CO
2
aviation effects, the separate report as referred to in Article 68(5) of this
Regulation shall at least contain the following information:
1.
2.
3.
4.
Data identifying the aircraft operator, and the call sign or other unique designators
used for air traffic control purposes, as well as relevant contact details;
Name and address of the verifier of the report;
The reporting year;
Reference to and version number of the latest approved monitoring plan and the date
from which it is applicable, reference to and version number of other monitoring
plans relevant for the reporting year;
Relevant changes in the operations and deviations from the approved monitoring
plan during the reporting period;
The aircraft registration numbers and types of aircraft used in the period covered by
the report to perform the aviation activities covered by Annex I to Directive
2003/87/EC carried out by the aircraft operator;
The total number of flights per State pair covered by the report;
The sum of CO
2
(e) of the monitored flights of the aircraft operator per aerodrome
pair, expressed in the climate metrics provided in Article 56a(2) of this Regulation.
A XML table containing per flight and as defined in Annex IIIa, Section 1 to this
Regulation, flight information, aircraft type, engine identifier and CO
2
(e), expressed
in the climate metrics provided in Article 56a(2) of this Regulation;
If the aircraft operator is not using NEATS to calculate the CO
2
(e), but own or third-
party IT tools as referred to in Article 56a(7)(b) of this Regulation, a description of
how efficacy is applied in those tools, in line with this Regulation and NEATS, to
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
EN
60
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0062.png
refine the GWP. If efficacy was not applied in the tools, the aircraft operator shall
provide a description explaining the reasons for not applying efficacy.’;
(d) Section 4 is amended as follows:
(i) point (6) is amended as follows:
- point (a) is replaced by the following:
‘(a) the total emissions expressed as t CO
2
, including CO
2
from biomass fuel streams which
do not comply with Article 38(5) of this Regulation, or from RFNBO or RCF source
streams which do not comply with Article 39a(3) of this Regulation, or from synthetic low-
carbon fuels source streams which do not comply with Article 39a(4) of this Regulation;’;
- point (d) is replaced by the following:
‘(d) emission factors, expressed in accordance with the requirements set out in Article 75f
of this Regulation; biomass fraction, zero-rated biomass fraction, RFNBO or RCF fraction,
zero-rated RFNBO or RCF fraction, synthetic low-carbon fraction, zero-rated synthetic
low-carbon fraction expressed as dimensionless fractions;’;
(ii) in point (7), points (a) and (b) are replaced by the following:
‘(a) a proxy for the net calorific value of the biomass, RFNBO or RCF or synthetic low-
carbon fuels fuel streams, where relevant;
(b) emissions, amounts and energy content of biofuels, bioliquids, biomass fuels, RFNBOs
and RCFs, synthetic low-carbon fuels released for consumption, expressed in t and TJ, and
information whether they comply with Article 38(5) or 39a(3) or 39a(4) of this Regulation;
emissions, amounts and energy content of biofuels, bioliquids, biomass fuels, RFNBOs
or RCFs released for consumption, expressed in t and TJ, and information whether they
comply with Article 38(5) or 39a(3) or 39a(4) of this Regulation;’;
(57)
in Annex Xa, the introductory sentence is replaced by the following:
‘Together with the information contained in the annual emission report pursuant to Annex
X to this Regulation, the operator shall submit the following information for each
purchased fuel as defined in Article 3, point (af) of Directive 2003/87/EC:’;
(58)
in Annex Xb, the introductory sentence is replaced by the following:
‘Together with the information contained in the annual emission report pursuant to Annex
X to this Regulation, the regulated entity shall submit the following information for each
purchased fuel as defined in Article 3, point (af), of Directive 2003/87/EC: ‘;
Article 2
Entry into force and application
This Regulation shall enter into force on the twentieth day following that of its publication in
the
Official Journal of the European Union.
It shall apply from 1 January 2024.
However, Article 1, points (2)(m), (42) to (46), (49), (57) and (58) shall apply from 1 July
2024.
Article 1, points (3), (5) to (8), (9)(c), (21), (25) to (27), (28)(a), (29), (35), (36), (38), (40),
(41), (47)(a) (i) and (ii), (47)(b)(i) first and fourth dash, (47)(b)(iii), (48)(a)(ii), (51), (52)(d),
EN
61
EN
KEF, Alm.del - 2023-24 - Bilag 388: Notat om komitésag vedr. revision af MR-forordningen om overvågning og rapportering af drivhusgasemissioner, fra udenrigsministeren
2898792_0063.png
(52)(e), (52)(f), (52)(g)(ii), (52)(h), (52)(i), (52)(j), (53), (55)(a)(ii), (55)(a)(iii), (55)(a)(iv),
(55)(b)(ii), (56)(a)(vi), (56)(c) shall apply from 1 January 2025.
This Regulation shall be binding in its entirety and directly applicable in all Member States.
Done at Brussels,
For the Commission
The President
Ursula VON DER LEYEN
EN
62
EN